Yesterday, 10:16 PM
Selecting the right skid steer for your construction or landscaping project is no small task. With so many models on the market, choosing between competitors like New Holland, John Deere, and Bobcat can be overwhelming. In this article, we will explore three popular models: the New Holland 220, John Deere 320E, and Bobcat S590. We'll compare their features, performance, and value, providing insights to help you make the best choice for your needs.
Performance Comparison
New Holland 220: Power Meets Versatility
The New Holland 220 is a strong contender in the skid steer market, offering a balance of power and versatility. Powered by a 74-horsepower engine, the NH 220 is capable of handling a variety of tasks, from digging to lifting. One of the standout features of this model is its high-flow hydraulic system, which provides extra power for demanding attachments like augers, mulchers, and trenchers.
For those who frequently work on rough terrain, the NH 220's long wheelbase provides a smoother ride, while its compact size allows for excellent maneuverability in tight spaces. Additionally, the NH 220 features an easy-to-use control system and is praised for its operator comfort.
However, the NH 220 isn’t without its drawbacks. While it boasts impressive lift capacity, some users report that its digging force could be better when compared to other models in the same category. But overall, it remains a solid choice for general construction tasks.
John Deere 320E: A Reliable Workhorse
The John Deere 320E is another solid option for operators looking for performance and durability. Known for its reliability and low operating costs, the 320E is powered by a 68-horsepower engine. While it doesn’t have as much horsepower as the NH 220, the JD 320E is still capable of performing tasks such as lifting, grading, and material handling.
A key selling point of the JD 320E is its ease of maintenance. The model’s design makes routine service tasks straightforward, and the accessibility of parts reduces downtime. Additionally, its hydraulic system is efficient, delivering a consistent flow to attachments.
The 320E is particularly valued for its stability and performance on uneven terrain. With a wide track option, operators can expect better flotation on soft ground, which is an asset when working in muddy or sandy conditions. While its lift capacity is lower than the NH 220, its maneuverability and rugged design make it an excellent choice for a wide range of environments.
Bobcat S590: Compact and Powerful
The Bobcat S590 is a popular choice for contractors who require a compact but powerful skid steer. With a 74-horsepower engine, the S590 offers excellent power for its size. One of the standout features of the S590 is its impressive lift height and capacity, which makes it a top choice for handling heavy loads.
The S590’s lift-arm design also sets it apart, providing enhanced visibility for the operator when loading or unloading materials. Its vertical lift path allows for better clearance, which is especially helpful when dealing with larger attachments.
In addition to its lifting power, the S590 excels in operator comfort. The model features a roomy, well-designed cabin with an adjustable seat, climate control, and user-friendly controls. It also boasts an intuitive control system, making it ideal for both new and experienced operators.
One area where the S590 could improve is its fuel efficiency. While it offers great performance, some users report that it consumes more fuel compared to other models, which could add to operating costs over time.
Hydraulic System and Attachments
The hydraulic system plays a crucial role in a skid steer's overall performance, especially when using various attachments. Both the New Holland 220 and Bobcat S590 offer high-flow options, which are ideal for running demanding attachments like hydraulic hammers or trenchers. The John Deere 320E, on the other hand, offers standard flow hydraulics, which are sufficient for most general tasks but may not be as capable when using high-flow attachments.
When choosing a skid steer, it's essential to consider the type of attachments you will be using most often. For operators who frequently use attachments requiring high hydraulic flow, the NH 220 and Bobcat S590 would be the better options. For those with simpler needs, the JD 320E can handle standard tasks with ease.
Operator Comfort and Ease of Use
Operator comfort and ease of use are important factors that directly impact productivity. The New Holland 220 features a spacious, well-laid-out cabin, and its controls are easy to master, making it a great choice for long hours of operation. The model also boasts good visibility, which is essential for ensuring safety on the job.
Similarly, the Bobcat S590 is known for its operator comfort. The cab is ergonomically designed, offering plenty of legroom and an adjustable seat. The control system is intuitive, and its easy-to-read display makes it simple to monitor the machine's performance.
The John Deere 320E, though functional, has received mixed reviews regarding its operator cabin. While it is comfortable enough for shorter tasks, some operators feel that the seating position and layout could be improved. That said, it’s still a solid choice for those prioritizing durability over luxury.
Maintenance and Durability
Skid steers are heavy-duty machines that are exposed to challenging conditions daily. As a result, regular maintenance and long-term durability are key considerations. In terms of durability, the John Deere 320E is renowned for its strong build and low maintenance costs. The design of the 320E allows for easier access to engine components, reducing downtime during maintenance.
Both the NH 220 and Bobcat S590 have earned reputations for their longevity, with a slight edge going to the Bobcat for its ruggedness on the job site. However, routine maintenance on the Bobcat can be more time-consuming due to its complex hydraulic system.
Final Thoughts: Which Skid Steer is Right for You?
When deciding between the New Holland 220, John Deere 320E, and Bobcat S590, the best choice depends on your specific needs and the type of work you do.
Performance Comparison
New Holland 220: Power Meets Versatility
The New Holland 220 is a strong contender in the skid steer market, offering a balance of power and versatility. Powered by a 74-horsepower engine, the NH 220 is capable of handling a variety of tasks, from digging to lifting. One of the standout features of this model is its high-flow hydraulic system, which provides extra power for demanding attachments like augers, mulchers, and trenchers.
For those who frequently work on rough terrain, the NH 220's long wheelbase provides a smoother ride, while its compact size allows for excellent maneuverability in tight spaces. Additionally, the NH 220 features an easy-to-use control system and is praised for its operator comfort.
However, the NH 220 isn’t without its drawbacks. While it boasts impressive lift capacity, some users report that its digging force could be better when compared to other models in the same category. But overall, it remains a solid choice for general construction tasks.
John Deere 320E: A Reliable Workhorse
The John Deere 320E is another solid option for operators looking for performance and durability. Known for its reliability and low operating costs, the 320E is powered by a 68-horsepower engine. While it doesn’t have as much horsepower as the NH 220, the JD 320E is still capable of performing tasks such as lifting, grading, and material handling.
A key selling point of the JD 320E is its ease of maintenance. The model’s design makes routine service tasks straightforward, and the accessibility of parts reduces downtime. Additionally, its hydraulic system is efficient, delivering a consistent flow to attachments.
The 320E is particularly valued for its stability and performance on uneven terrain. With a wide track option, operators can expect better flotation on soft ground, which is an asset when working in muddy or sandy conditions. While its lift capacity is lower than the NH 220, its maneuverability and rugged design make it an excellent choice for a wide range of environments.
Bobcat S590: Compact and Powerful
The Bobcat S590 is a popular choice for contractors who require a compact but powerful skid steer. With a 74-horsepower engine, the S590 offers excellent power for its size. One of the standout features of the S590 is its impressive lift height and capacity, which makes it a top choice for handling heavy loads.
The S590’s lift-arm design also sets it apart, providing enhanced visibility for the operator when loading or unloading materials. Its vertical lift path allows for better clearance, which is especially helpful when dealing with larger attachments.
In addition to its lifting power, the S590 excels in operator comfort. The model features a roomy, well-designed cabin with an adjustable seat, climate control, and user-friendly controls. It also boasts an intuitive control system, making it ideal for both new and experienced operators.
One area where the S590 could improve is its fuel efficiency. While it offers great performance, some users report that it consumes more fuel compared to other models, which could add to operating costs over time.
Hydraulic System and Attachments
The hydraulic system plays a crucial role in a skid steer's overall performance, especially when using various attachments. Both the New Holland 220 and Bobcat S590 offer high-flow options, which are ideal for running demanding attachments like hydraulic hammers or trenchers. The John Deere 320E, on the other hand, offers standard flow hydraulics, which are sufficient for most general tasks but may not be as capable when using high-flow attachments.
When choosing a skid steer, it's essential to consider the type of attachments you will be using most often. For operators who frequently use attachments requiring high hydraulic flow, the NH 220 and Bobcat S590 would be the better options. For those with simpler needs, the JD 320E can handle standard tasks with ease.
Operator Comfort and Ease of Use
Operator comfort and ease of use are important factors that directly impact productivity. The New Holland 220 features a spacious, well-laid-out cabin, and its controls are easy to master, making it a great choice for long hours of operation. The model also boasts good visibility, which is essential for ensuring safety on the job.
Similarly, the Bobcat S590 is known for its operator comfort. The cab is ergonomically designed, offering plenty of legroom and an adjustable seat. The control system is intuitive, and its easy-to-read display makes it simple to monitor the machine's performance.
The John Deere 320E, though functional, has received mixed reviews regarding its operator cabin. While it is comfortable enough for shorter tasks, some operators feel that the seating position and layout could be improved. That said, it’s still a solid choice for those prioritizing durability over luxury.
Maintenance and Durability
Skid steers are heavy-duty machines that are exposed to challenging conditions daily. As a result, regular maintenance and long-term durability are key considerations. In terms of durability, the John Deere 320E is renowned for its strong build and low maintenance costs. The design of the 320E allows for easier access to engine components, reducing downtime during maintenance.
Both the NH 220 and Bobcat S590 have earned reputations for their longevity, with a slight edge going to the Bobcat for its ruggedness on the job site. However, routine maintenance on the Bobcat can be more time-consuming due to its complex hydraulic system.
Final Thoughts: Which Skid Steer is Right for You?
When deciding between the New Holland 220, John Deere 320E, and Bobcat S590, the best choice depends on your specific needs and the type of work you do.
- If you require high hydraulic flow and heavy lifting power, the New Holland 220 is an excellent choice. It’s well-suited for those who regularly use demanding attachments and need a powerful, versatile machine.
- For those seeking a reliable workhorse with excellent flotation and low operating costs, the John Deere 320E stands out. It’s perfect for contractors who need a durable and easy-to-maintain skid steer for general tasks.
- If you prioritize lift height, operator comfort, and a compact design, the Bobcat S590 is a great option. It excels in both performance and comfort but may come at a higher fuel cost.
