Mini Excavator Comparison: Deere 17G vs. Bobcat E20

[MikePhua]

When it comes to choosing a mini excavator, two popular models that often come up for comparison are the Deere 17G and the Bobcat E20. Both of these machines offer great versatility and performance in compact construction tasks, but they differ in various aspects such as power, hydraulics, size, and functionality. In this article, we’ll compare these two models in terms of specifications, performance, and features to help you determine which one best suits your needs.
1. Overview of the Deere 17G and Bobcat E20
The Deere 17G and Bobcat E20 are both compact mini excavators designed for tight spaces and light construction work. The Deere 17G offers excellent hydraulic performance and efficiency, while the Bobcat E20 is known for its strong digging capabilities and high maneuverability. Both machines come with a range of attachments and options that can be customized for specific tasks.
2. Specifications Comparison
Here’s a brief comparison of key specifications between the Deere 17G and Bobcat E20:

• Operating Weight:
  • Deere 17G: 1,700 kg (3,748 lbs)
    
  • Bobcat E20: 2,000 kg (4,409 lbs)
    
• Engine Power:
  • Deere 17G: 14.7 hp
    
  • Bobcat E20: 19.6 hp
    
• Digging Depth:
  • Deere 17G: 2.44 m (8 ft)
    
  • Bobcat E20: 2.6 m (8.5 ft)
    
• Maximum Reach:
  • Deere 17G: 3.69 m (12 ft)
    
  • Bobcat E20: 3.81 m (12.5 ft)
    
• Track Width:
  • Deere 17G: 1.0 m (3.3 ft) (expandable up to 1.3 m / 4.3 ft)
    
  • Bobcat E20: 1.0 m (3.3 ft) (expandable up to 1.3 m / 4.3 ft)
    

3. Performance and Capabilities

• Hydraulics and Power:
  The Deere 17G is equipped with a 14.7 hp engine, which is sufficient for a variety of light digging tasks, offering good fuel efficiency and smooth operation. On the other hand, the Bobcat E20’s 19.6 hp engine provides more power, which can be beneficial for heavier lifting and digging. The additional horsepower in the Bobcat E20 allows it to perform better in certain tasks that demand more power, such as tougher digging or lifting heavier loads.
  
• Digging Depth and Reach:
  The Bobcat E20 outperforms the Deere 17G in both digging depth and maximum reach. The Bobcat’s digging depth of 2.6 meters (8.5 feet) provides it with a slight edge in terms of depth, while its reach of 3.81 meters (12.5 feet) gives it a longer working radius, which can be useful in reaching further areas without repositioning the machine.
  
• Stability and Size:
  While both machines feature expandable tracks, the Bobcat E20 is slightly heavier, which may contribute to better stability when working on uneven terrain. The Deere 17G, however, is lighter and more compact, making it ideal for confined spaces and easy transport between job sites.
  

4. Maneuverability and Ease of Use
Both the Deere 17G and Bobcat E20 are designed for ease of use in confined spaces. The Deere 17G features a tail swing that allows it to operate close to obstacles, while the Bobcat E20 also offers excellent maneuverability, thanks to its compact design and smooth control systems. Operators will find both machines easy to navigate through tight areas, but the Bobcat’s additional horsepower and slightly better reach may give it an advantage in certain conditions.
5. Maintenance and Durability
Both machines are built with durability in mind, featuring robust components and easy access for maintenance. The Deere 17G has a reputation for reliability, and its fuel-efficient engine reduces operating costs. Similarly, the Bobcat E20 is known for its high-quality construction and longevity, with a strong service network to support owners. Regular maintenance for both machines is crucial to ensure their longevity, including checking hydraulic systems, engine performance, and the tracks.
6. Conclusion: Which Mini Excavator is Right for You?

• Deere 17G: If you are looking for a lightweight, fuel-efficient, and highly maneuverable mini excavator for light-duty tasks in confined spaces, the Deere 17G is a great option. It is well-suited for residential projects, landscaping, and small construction tasks that don’t require heavy digging or lifting.
  
• Bobcat E20: For those who need more power and depth, the Bobcat E20 is a stronger performer, particularly for tasks that require extra digging depth, reach, and lifting capacity. It is ideal for larger or more demanding jobs, and its additional horsepower makes it a better choice for challenging terrain or heavier loads.
  

Ultimately, the right choice between the Deere 17G and Bobcat E20 depends on the specific needs of your project. If you need a compact, versatile machine for lighter tasks, the Deere 17G will serve you well. However, if your work demands more power and reach, the Bobcat E20 is the better option.