T86 vs 333G: A Comparison of Two Popular Compact Track Loaders

[MikePhua]

When choosing a compact track loader (CTL) for demanding tasks, understanding the differences between models can significantly impact operational efficiency. Two popular machines that often come up in comparison are the Bobcat T86 and the John Deere 333G. Both are heavy-duty CTLs with impressive power and capabilities, but they each bring unique features and benefits to the table. In this article, we will break down the features, specifications, and advantages of these two models to help you make an informed decision.
Overview of the Bobcat T86
The Bobcat T86 is part of Bobcat’s extensive lineup of compact track loaders. It is known for its powerful performance, durability, and versatility in various applications, from construction and landscaping to agriculture. The T86 is part of Bobcat’s T Series of track loaders, which are designed to provide maximum stability, traction, and lifting capabilities.
Key Features of the Bobcat T86:

• Engine Power: 100 horsepower, making it one of the most powerful machines in the Bobcat CTL lineup.
  
• Operating Capacity: The T86 offers a rated operating capacity of about 3,400 lbs, which allows it to handle heavy loads with ease.
  
• Hydraulic Performance: The T86 features impressive hydraulics, with a high-flow hydraulics system capable of handling demanding attachments like hydraulic augers, planers, and grapples.
  
• Lift Height: The T86 offers a lift height of approximately 130 inches, making it suitable for high-stack operations and other applications that require extended reach.
  
• Dimensions and Maneuverability: It has a compact and agile design with a width of around 78 inches, which allows it to fit into tight spaces without sacrificing power or lift capacity.
  

The Bobcat T86 stands out for its exceptional power-to-weight ratio and ability to tackle the toughest jobs in a variety of industries. Its powerful engine, combined with a smooth hydraulic system, ensures efficient operation when using attachments like trenchers, snow blades, and pallet forks.
Overview of the John Deere 333G
The John Deere 333G is another industry-leading compact track loader. As part of Deere’s G-Series, it is engineered for heavy-duty work while maintaining high levels of comfort, durability, and ease of operation. The 333G is often praised for its stability on rough terrain, robust power, and advanced technology systems.
Key Features of the John Deere 333G:

• Engine Power: Equipped with a 99 horsepower engine, the 333G offers slightly less horsepower than the Bobcat T86 but is still highly capable for most heavy-duty tasks.
  
• Operating Capacity: The 333G has a rated operating capacity of 3,700 lbs, making it capable of lifting and moving larger loads compared to the Bobcat T86.
  
• Hydraulic Performance: The 333G features a high-flow hydraulics system with a flow rate of around 37 gallons per minute (GPM), providing excellent performance when operating attachments like grapples, soil conditioners, and trenchers.
  
• Lift Height: The 333G offers a lift height of approximately 131 inches, slightly higher than the T86, which makes it suitable for tasks requiring high dumping and reach.
  
• Dimensions and Maneuverability: The 333G is about 74 inches wide, slightly narrower than the T86, which allows it to work in tighter spaces. Despite its narrower width, the machine’s low center of gravity contributes to better stability on uneven terrain.
  

The John Deere 333G’s combination of robust engine power, high lifting capacity, and advanced hydraulics makes it a solid choice for operators seeking a reliable machine for tough jobs.
Comparing Performance and Power
Both the Bobcat T86 and John Deere 333G are designed for high-performance applications, but there are key differences in their capabilities and strengths:

1. Horsepower and Engine Power:
   • The Bobcat T86 has a slight edge in terms of engine power, with its 100-horsepower engine. This allows it to handle more demanding tasks and attachments that require higher power output.
     
   • The John Deere 333G, with its 99-horsepower engine, offers slightly less raw power but is still very capable for most heavy-duty applications.
     
2. Lifting Capacity:
   • The John Deere 333G wins in terms of rated operating capacity, with a maximum of 3,700 lbs, compared to the T86’s 3,400 lbs. This means that the Deere machine can lift slightly heavier loads, which can be crucial in certain situations where lifting capacity is a priority.
     
3. Lift Height:
   • The John Deere 333G and the Bobcat T86 offer very similar lift heights (around 130 inches). Both machines are designed for high-reach tasks, but the Deere’s lift height is marginally higher, making it a better choice for applications requiring maximum vertical reach.
     
4. Hydraulic Flow:
   • Both machines offer high-flow hydraulic systems, but the John Deere 333G comes with a slightly better hydraulic flow rate at 37 GPM, compared to Bobcat’s high-flow system that provides 31 GPM. This can give the 333G an advantage when using hydraulic-driven attachments that demand a higher flow rate.
     

Comfort, Maneuverability, and Technology

1. Operator Comfort:
   • The Bobcat T86 comes with a comfortable cab and air-suspension seat, reducing operator fatigue during long hours. The controls are well laid out and easy to use, providing a smooth experience even when operating heavy attachments.
     
   • The John Deere 333G also offers an ergonomic operator station with a comfortable seat, excellent visibility, and user-friendly controls. The cab is spacious, providing plenty of room for the operator to move comfortably, even during long shifts.
     
2. Maneuverability:
   • The Bobcat T86 is slightly wider than the John Deere 333G, making it a bit less agile in tight spaces. However, the wider stance provides more stability, especially when working on uneven ground.
     
   • The John Deere 333G, being narrower, offers better maneuverability in confined spaces, but still maintains excellent stability thanks to its low center of gravity.
     
3. Technology Features:
   • Both machines offer advanced technology features such as telematics for fleet management and performance monitoring. However, John Deere’s JDLink telematics system is often considered more robust and feature-rich, providing detailed machine diagnostics and real-time location tracking.
     
   • Bobcat offers its own telematics system, Bobcat Plus, which provides similar capabilities but is often considered less intuitive compared to Deere’s system.
     

Final Verdict: Which One to Choose?
The choice between the Bobcat T86 and John Deere 333G largely depends on your specific needs and application requirements. Here’s a summary of the key points:

• Choose the Bobcat T86 if:
  • You need a more powerful engine (100 hp).
    
  • You’re looking for a machine that offers exceptional lift height and is equipped to handle demanding attachments.
    
  • You value a well-established, reliable machine with a proven track record in various industries.
    
• Choose the John Deere 333G if:
  • You require a higher rated operating capacity (3,700 lbs).
    
  • You prioritize advanced hydraulic flow and slightly better lifting capabilities.
    
  • You prefer a more agile machine for tight spaces, with a slightly narrower profile.
    

Both machines are excellent choices in the world of compact track loaders, and your decision should come down to the specific features and performance characteristics that align with your tasks and work environment. Either way, both models will offer you years of reliable service in heavy-duty applications.