2 hours ago
Overview
Choosing between the Caterpillar 308 and the John Deere 85P excavators requires understanding their core specifications, performance traits, and value proposition. Both machines cater to the 8-ton excavator class, ideal for construction, landscaping, and utility tasks with tight spaces and moderate digging needs.
Engine and Power
The Caterpillar 308 provides higher breakout forces, integrated monitoring, and dealer support advantages suiting operators requiring reliability and power at a premium price. In contrast, the John Deere 85P delivers commendable performance with a spacious cab and modern visibility features at a lower price point, appealing to budget-conscious buyers and operators seeking comfort. The decision hinges on balancing power, operator preference, service infrastructure, and budget constraints for optimal machine pairing with jobsite demands.
Choosing between the Caterpillar 308 and the John Deere 85P excavators requires understanding their core specifications, performance traits, and value proposition. Both machines cater to the 8-ton excavator class, ideal for construction, landscaping, and utility tasks with tight spaces and moderate digging needs.
Engine and Power
- The Cat 308 typically features a 74.5 hp (approximately 55 kW) turbocharged engine providing robust digging power and consistent hydraulic response.
- The John Deere 85P is powered by a slightly smaller engine, producing around 67.6 hp (50.4 kW), turbocharged as well, offering efficient fuel consumption balanced with sufficient horsepower for mid-size excavator tasks.
- Cat 308 boasts a stick breakout force of approximately 40.1 kN (9,015 lbf), which is 23% higher compared to the John Deere 85P at around 30.7 kN (6,902 lbf). This translates into better digging efficiency and ability to handle compacted or embedded materials.
- Both machines have advanced hydraulic systems with variable flow pumps and auxiliary flow for attachments, but Cat 308’s continuous auxiliary flow control facilitates smoother and more precise implement operation.
- The Cat 308 provides a joystick-operated swing boom, a pattern changer accessible from the seat, and a standard rear-view camera integrated into the operator’s monitor, enhancing visibility and safety.
- John Deere 85P offers a spacious cab with 270-degree camera system and LED work lights standard, improving site awareness and working conditions during low light.
- The Deere’s larger cab and enhanced visibility are preferred by operators working long shifts demanding operator comfort.
- Caterpillar machines benefit from an extensive dealer network and robust telematics support, including real-time diagnostics via the COMPASS monitoring system.
- John Deere offers excellent service accessibility with easy-open compartments and ground-level fuel filling for efficient maintenance.
- Service intervals on the Cat 308 are designed for longer spans, potentially reducing downtime, whereas some operators mention shorter intervals on comparable Deere models, possibly influencing total ownership costs.
- The John Deere 85P typically is priced lower than the Cat 308, making it attractive to buyers looking for value without sacrificing too much capability.
- Buyers favoring parts interoperability, operator familiarity, and dealer support might gravitate toward the Cat if they already own Cat equipment.
- The Deere's price advantage and comfortable cab may appeal to those newer to the industry or focusing on lower upfront ownership costs.
- Stick Breakout Force: The pushing or pulling force exerted by the excavator's arm, critical for efficient digging.
- Turbocharged Engine: An engine with forced induction increasing power output without increasing engine size.
- Auxiliary Flow Control: Hydraulic systems allowing control of additional work tools like breakers or grapples.
- Pattern Changer: Device enabling operator to switch control patterns for joystick movements related to boom/bucket functions.
- Telematics: Systems for remote monitoring of equipment health and performance.
The Caterpillar 308 provides higher breakout forces, integrated monitoring, and dealer support advantages suiting operators requiring reliability and power at a premium price. In contrast, the John Deere 85P delivers commendable performance with a spacious cab and modern visibility features at a lower price point, appealing to budget-conscious buyers and operators seeking comfort. The decision hinges on balancing power, operator preference, service infrastructure, and budget constraints for optimal machine pairing with jobsite demands.
