Moving Up from the Bobcat T190: Upgrading Your Skid Steer Loader

[MikePhua]

For many construction and landscaping professionals, a skid steer loader is one of the most versatile and essential pieces of equipment in their fleet. The Bobcat T190 is a popular model due to its compact size, strong lifting capabilities, and reliable performance. However, as projects grow and job demands change, there comes a time when operators may consider upgrading to a larger, more powerful machine. This article explores the considerations and options when moving up from the Bobcat T190 to a more advanced skid steer loader.
Why Consider Upgrading from the Bobcat T190?
The Bobcat T190, often regarded as a workhorse in smaller construction tasks, has served its owners well in applications such as landscaping, site prep, and even snow removal. But as businesses expand or project needs become more demanding, upgrading to a larger skid steer loader offers distinct advantages.

1. Increased Lifting Capacity:
   One of the primary reasons for upgrading from the T190 is the need for a greater lifting capacity. While the T190 has a lift capacity of around 1,900 lbs, many larger skid steers in the Bobcat and Case lineup offer lift capacities closer to 2,400 lbs or more. This increase can make a significant difference when handling larger materials, such as pallets, concrete blocks, or heavy attachments.
   
2. Improved Reach and Hydraulic Power:
   Larger models typically feature a longer reach and more powerful hydraulics, making them more effective for tasks such as lifting taller loads or operating more demanding attachments like augers, grapples, or pallet forks. This is particularly valuable on sites where height and precision are critical.
   
3. Better Stability and Ride Quality:
   As you move up to larger models, the weight distribution, track width, and suspension system generally improve, leading to better stability when lifting heavy loads. Additionally, a more powerful machine typically offers smoother ride quality, reducing operator fatigue and improving safety.
   
4. Larger Work Area Coverage:
   Larger skid steers also come with wider tracks or tires, which help distribute the machine’s weight over a larger area. This reduces ground pressure, which is particularly beneficial when working on softer or more sensitive terrain, like lawns or newly seeded soil.
   

What to Look for When Upgrading
Upgrading from the T190 means you're transitioning to a machine that is capable of handling larger and more challenging jobs. Here are some critical factors to consider:

1. Machine Size and Power:
   When upgrading, you'll be looking at models like the Bobcat T870, Case 570N, or even CAT's 262D. These machines provide more power, a larger footprint, and a variety of features that enhance performance. Before making a purchase, consider the types of jobs you'll be tackling. For example, if you need a machine for lifting heavy loads or handling attachments that require a significant amount of hydraulic power, opting for a model like the Bobcat T870 with its higher horsepower and lift capacity would be an excellent choice.
   
2. Attachment Compatibility:
   A significant advantage of upgrading is the ability to use a broader range of attachments. While the T190 is compatible with many basic attachments like buckets, forks, and brooms, larger models often have the hydraulic capacity to operate more complex or heavy-duty attachments such as mulching heads, stump grinders, or snowplows.
   
3. Track vs. Tire Models:
   Bobcat offers both tire and track-based skid steer models, and your decision will depend on the type of terrain you'll be working on. Track-based machines, such as the Bobcat T870 or the CASE TR340, offer better flotation on soft ground and provide superior traction on rough terrain. If you're primarily working in a more compact, urban environment, a tire-based machine might be better for you.
   
4. Operator Comfort and Safety:
   Larger skid steers often come with upgraded cabins, including better visibility, air conditioning, improved seat suspension, and enhanced ergonomic controls. Since skid steers are often operated for long hours in various weather conditions, these comfort features can significantly increase productivity and reduce operator fatigue.
   

Top Models to Consider When Moving Up from the Bobcat T190
When you're ready to move up from the T190, here are some models that should be on your radar. These machines are built for more demanding work while offering superior capabilities compared to the T190.

1. Bobcat T870:
   The T870 is one of Bobcat’s largest and most powerful skid steers. With a rated operating capacity of 3,475 lbs and an impressive 92.5 hp, this machine offers unmatched power, stability, and versatility. It's a fantastic choice for contractors looking to handle heavier attachments, lift larger loads, and take on tougher terrain.
   
2. CASE TR340:
   CASE’s TR340 is another strong contender, offering similar lifting capacities and horsepower as the T870. It’s known for its smooth ride, fuel efficiency, and powerful hydraulics. Its cooling system is robust, which ensures that the engine and hydraulics stay optimal under heavy load conditions.
   
3. CAT 262D:
   If you're looking for a machine that strikes a balance between power and compact size, the CAT 262D is an excellent option. With a rated operating capacity of 2,700 lbs and a powerful 74.3 hp engine, this machine offers a strong performance in tight spaces. CAT’s skid steers also come with a comfortable operator’s cabin and excellent safety features.
   
4. John Deere 333G:
   The John Deere 333G is a powerful and efficient option for those looking to upsize from the T190. With a 3,300 lbs operating capacity and 100 hp, this machine is perfect for handling demanding tasks. The high flow hydraulics and self-leveling loader make it suitable for a range of attachments, from heavy-duty buckets to mulching heads.
   

Considerations When Transitioning to a Larger Machine
Upgrading to a larger skid steer like the T870 or the TR340 is exciting but requires careful consideration:

1. Increased Maintenance Costs:
   Larger machines generally have more complex systems and components, meaning maintenance and repair costs could be higher. Before upgrading, make sure you're comfortable with the cost of maintaining a more powerful machine, as well as any additional spare parts you may need to keep on hand.
   
2. Transporting the Equipment:
   Larger machines require larger trailers for transport. If you plan to haul your skid steer to different job sites, ensure your current trailer can accommodate the size and weight of the new model. This could mean investing in a more heavy-duty trailer to safely transport the equipment.
   
3. Operator Training:
   Larger machines can be more difficult to operate due to their size, power, and more complex systems. Ensure your operators are properly trained in the new machine’s capabilities and safety features. Some manufacturers, like Bobcat and CASE, offer training programs and certifications to ensure your team is prepared to operate the equipment safely.
   

The Bottom Line: Is Upgrading Worth It?
Upgrading from the Bobcat T190 to a larger skid steer is a significant decision that can provide substantial benefits, especially if your business is growing and tackling more complex projects. While larger skid steers offer enhanced capabilities, they also require careful consideration of maintenance, costs, and operator training. Ultimately, the decision should be based on the types of jobs you plan to take on, the kind of attachments you'll use, and the terrain you'll be working in.
For those seeking more power, greater lifting capacity, and enhanced versatility, upgrading to models like the Bobcat T870, CASE TR340, or CAT 262D can be a game-changer. With the right machine, you'll be able to handle bigger jobs, work more efficiently, and improve the profitability of your projects.