Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Is the Mecalac Excavator a Game-Changer or a Niche Marvel?
#1
Origins of a European Innovator
Mecalac, a French manufacturer founded in 1974, began as a niche producer of compact construction equipment tailored for urban environments. The company’s philosophy has always emphasized multifunctionality, compactness, and operator efficiency. Over the decades, Mecalac expanded its footprint across Europe, acquiring Terex’s compact equipment division in 2017 and integrating German and British engineering into its portfolio. Today, Mecalac machines are widely used across European cities, where space constraints and versatility are paramount.
Despite its European success, Mecalac’s penetration into the North American market has been slow. As of 2024, the company has only a handful of dealers in the U.S., primarily clustered around the Northeast and Pacific Northwest. This limited distribution network has raised concerns among potential buyers about service accessibility and parts availability.
Design Philosophy and Technical Highlights
Mecalac’s excavators, particularly the 6MCR, 8MCR, and 9MWR models, are engineered to combine the agility of a skid steer with the digging power of a conventional excavator. The standout feature is the two-piece boom, which allows for a wide range of motion and compact operation. This design enables tasks such as trenching, lifting, and grading to be performed in tight spaces without repositioning the machine.
Key specifications of the Mecalac 8MCR include:
  • Operating weight: ~9,000 kg
  • Engine power: 55.4 kW (74.3 hp)
  • Travel speed: up to 10 km/h (high-speed undercarriage)
  • Hydraulic flow: 130 l/min
  • Bucket breakout force: ~5,000 daN
The high-speed undercarriage is particularly notable. Unlike traditional excavators that crawl at 3–5 km/h, Mecalac’s MCR series can reach speeds up to 10 km/h, reducing transit time on job sites. This feature is ideal for utility contractors and landscapers who need to move quickly between tasks.
Terminology Note
  • Two-piece boom: A boom design with two articulated segments, allowing for greater flexibility and reach.
  • High-speed undercarriage: A drive system enabling faster travel speeds than conventional excavators.
  • Hydraulic flow: The volume of hydraulic fluid delivered per minute, affecting attachment performance.
Versatility vs. Specialization
The Mecalac excavator is often described as a “Swiss Army knife” of compact equipment. Its ability to switch between tasks—excavation, lifting, grading—makes it attractive for small contractors and municipalities. However, this versatility comes with trade-offs. Operators accustomed to high-flow hydraulic systems or heavy lifting capacities may find the Mecalac underpowered for certain applications.
One operator compared the Mecalac to the Kobelco Blade Runner, a hybrid dozer-excavator that gained popularity in the early 2000s. The Blade Runner was praised for its productivity in one-man operations, and the Mecalac evokes similar admiration among those who value efficiency over brute force.
Dealer Access and Self-Sufficiency
A recurring theme among users is the challenge of dealer proximity. With some dealers located hours away, maintenance and warranty support can be cumbersome. However, many seasoned operators argue that self-sufficiency mitigates this issue. One veteran shared his experience maintaining Swiss, Canadian, and German machines without relying on dealers, using hydraulic schematics and remote tech support to troubleshoot issues.
This DIY ethos is particularly strong in rural America, where operators often fabricate parts in their own shops. For these users, Mecalac’s design—praised for its service accessibility and logical layout—offers a refreshing alternative to machines burdened by proprietary electronics and dealer-only diagnostics.
Remote Diagnostics and the Global Shift
The story of a Kaiser excavator owner who received remote diagnostics from Germany via CDMA phone illustrates the potential of modern telematics. Although the anecdote predates smartphones, it underscores the feasibility of remote support. Today, many manufacturers offer cloud-based diagnostics, but some U.S. dealers still require in-person visits, often tied to subscription models that prioritize data collection over customer service.
This tension between innovation and control is not unique to Mecalac. As emissions regulations and electronic systems become more complex, operators increasingly depend on dealer software to resolve issues—even those unrelated to emissions. This dependency has sparked debates about right-to-repair and the future of independent maintenance.
Field Impressions and Operator Feedback
Operators who have demoed Mecalac machines report mixed impressions. The design is universally praised, especially the ease of access to components and the intuitive control layout. However, concerns remain about the exposed hydraulic lines on the boom, which may be vulnerable in wooded environments or demolition sites.
One user recounted sitting in a 9MWR at a German dealership, impressed by the ergonomics but unable to test the machine due to language barriers. Another finally purchased a Mecalac three years after initial interest, inviting fellow operators to visit and experience it firsthand.
Sales and Market Penetration
While Mecalac does not publicly disclose global sales figures, industry estimates suggest modest penetration in North America. In contrast, the company enjoys strong sales in France, Germany, and the UK, where compact urban construction is prevalent. The slow U.S. rollout may reflect strategic caution or logistical hurdles, but it also presents an opportunity for early adopters to gain a competitive edge.
Recommendations for Prospective Buyers
  • Evaluate your workflow: Mecalac excels in environments where versatility and speed outweigh raw power.
  • Consider dealer access: If you're comfortable with self-maintenance, distance may be less of a concern.
  • Demo before purchase: The unique control scheme and boom articulation require hands-on experience.
  • Plan for parts: Stock common wear items and familiarize yourself with hydraulic and electrical schematics.
  • Explore remote support: Ask dealers about telematics and diagnostic capabilities.
Conclusion
The Mecalac excavator is not a one-size-fits-all solution, but for operators seeking a compact, multifunctional machine with European engineering finesse, it offers compelling advantages. Its design reflects decades of refinement, and while its U.S. presence remains limited, those willing to embrace its quirks may find it to be a transformative addition to their fleet.
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Understanding the Yanmar B3 Mini Excavator and Its Maintenance Needs MikePhua 0 4 2 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  Choosing the Right Mini Excavator for Residential and Light Commercial Work MikePhua 0 4 2 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  Tracing the History of a Daewoo Excavator by Serial Number MikePhua 0 4 2 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  The Enduring Utility of the Cat 312B Excavator MikePhua 0 4 2 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  Kobelco 140 SRLC Excavator in Field Service and Repair MikePhua 0 4 3 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  Hitachi EX75UR Excavator Overview and Owner Insights MikePhua 0 4 3 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  Komatsu PC45-1 Excavator Overview MikePhua 0 4 3 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  Is the Hitachi EX60 Excavator Worth It? MikePhua 0 4 3 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  TB 175: An In-depth Look at the Takeuchi Mini Excavator MikePhua 0 4 4 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  CAT 320 Excavator Pricing and Performance in Modern Earthmoving MikePhua 0 4 4 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  Choosing Between a TLB, Mini Excavator, and Tractor for Versatile Site Work MikePhua 0 4 4 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  How Good Are You with an Excavator MikePhua 0 4 5 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  EC 450: A Comprehensive Overview of a Reliable Excavator MikePhua 0 4 5 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  John Deere 37G Compact Excavator and Its Role in Tight-Space Earthmoving MikePhua 0 4 5 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua
  What Should You Buy After Selling a Takeuchi TB015 Mini Excavator MikePhua 0 4 5 hours ago
Last Post: MikePhua

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)