Comparing the CAT 279C and the Bobcat TL250: Which Is Better for Your Needs?

[MikePhua]

When it comes to heavy equipment, especially compact track loaders (CTLs), the CAT 279C and the Bobcat TL250 are two models that often come up in discussions. Both machines are designed to handle rough terrains, dig, lift, and move materials, making them popular choices for construction, landscaping, and other heavy-duty applications. However, the differences between these two models are significant and choosing the right one depends on various factors, including work requirements, machine performance, and specific job site conditions.
Overview of the CAT 279C
The CAT 279C is part of Caterpillar’s mid-sized range of compact track loaders. Known for its durability and versatility, the 279C is designed for demanding work conditions, such as construction sites with soft, muddy, or uneven ground. One of the standout features of the 279C is its advanced hydraulic system and the ability to provide impressive lift capacities and breakout force, making it ideal for digging, material handling, and grading.
Key Specifications:

• Engine Power: 74.3 hp (55.4 kW)
  
• Operating Weight: 8,442 lbs (3,825 kg)
  
• Rated Operating Capacity: 2,300 lbs (1,043 kg)
  
• Lift Height: 10 ft (3.05 m)
  
• Hydraulic Flow: 17.7 gpm (67.0 l/min)
  

The CAT 279C has a renowned reputation for its high performance in tough conditions. The undercarriage is designed to provide excellent traction, which makes it particularly good at maneuvering through rough terrains. The machine’s versatility is one of its strongest features, with various attachments that make it a go-to option for tasks ranging from trenching to snow removal.
Overview of the Bobcat TL250
The Bobcat TL250 is part of Bobcat’s line of high-performance compact track loaders. This machine is designed with a focus on speed, agility, and lifting capability, making it a strong contender in various industries such as agriculture, landscaping, and construction. The TL250 is known for its powerful engine and superior lifting capacities, offering a great balance of performance and comfort for the operator.
Key Specifications:

• Engine Power: 74.3 hp (55.4 kW)
  
• Operating Weight: 8,350 lbs (3,782 kg)
  
• Rated Operating Capacity: 2,500 lbs (1,134 kg)
  
• Lift Height: 10.2 ft (3.1 m)
  
• Hydraulic Flow: 17.9 gpm (67.8 l/min)
  

The Bobcat TL250 offers great stability and is equipped with an advanced suspension system that reduces operator fatigue, making it a top choice for long workdays. The machine is also highly versatile, with a wide range of attachments available for various applications.
Key Differences Between the CAT 279C and the Bobcat TL250
While the CAT 279C and Bobcat TL250 share many similarities in terms of engine power and performance, several differences can influence which model is the better choice for a specific task.

1. Lift Capacity
   The Bobcat TL250 has a slightly higher rated operating capacity (2,500 lbs vs. 2,300 lbs), which means it can lift a little more weight. For tasks that involve frequent heavy lifting, such as moving bulky materials or lifting heavy attachments, the TL250 may be the better choice.
   
2. Operating Weight
   The CAT 279C is a bit heavier than the Bobcat TL250 by about 92 lbs. While this may not sound like much, the added weight can contribute to better stability when carrying heavy loads or working on uneven ground. The extra weight also helps the 279C provide better traction on loose surfaces.
   
3. Hydraulic Flow
   The hydraulic flow of the CAT 279C is 17.7 gpm, while the Bobcat TL250 offers 17.9 gpm, making the latter a slightly more efficient machine in terms of hydraulic performance. Hydraulic efficiency is important when using high-flow attachments such as stump grinders or trenchers, and a small difference in hydraulic flow can make a noticeable impact.
   
4. Lift Height
   The Bobcat TL250 offers a slightly higher lift height at 10.2 ft, compared to the CAT 279C's 10 ft. While the difference is minimal, a higher lift height can be an advantage for certain tasks like loading materials onto trucks or lifting tall loads.
   
5. Maneuverability and Suspension
   Both machines have excellent maneuverability, but the Bobcat TL250 stands out with its superior suspension system. The suspension allows for a smoother ride over rough terrains, which can be beneficial when working in more uneven or bumpy areas. The CAT 279C, while also capable of navigating rough terrain, has a firmer ride compared to the TL250.
   

Performance in Different Job Conditions
The decision to choose between the CAT 279C and Bobcat TL250 often boils down to the specific requirements of the job at hand.

• Construction and Landscaping: Both the CAT 279C and the Bobcat TL250 are excellent choices for construction, landscaping, and general material handling. However, if you need a machine that can handle heavier loads more frequently, the TL250's higher lifting capacity may be beneficial.
  
• Mud and Slippery Terrain: The CAT 279C’s heavier weight and superior traction make it more suitable for slippery, muddy, or uneven ground conditions. Its design provides better weight distribution, helping prevent the machine from getting stuck.
  
• Long Work Hours and Operator Comfort: For long hours of operation, the Bobcat TL250’s suspension system gives it an edge in operator comfort. While the CAT 279C is well-built for durability and reliability, the smoother ride offered by the Bobcat TL250 can significantly reduce operator fatigue.
  
• Versatility: Both machines are highly versatile and compatible with a wide range of attachments. Whether you need to perform digging, lifting, grading, or sweeping, both the 279C and TL250 can get the job done. The key here is ensuring that the machine you select matches the requirements of your attachments, particularly when it comes to hydraulic flow and lifting capacity.
  

Choosing the Right Machine for Your Needs
Both the CAT 279C and the Bobcat TL250 are powerful compact track loaders capable of handling a variety of tasks with ease. The right choice depends on several factors, such as the weight of the materials you plan to move, the terrain you'll be working on, and the comfort of the operator.
If your priority is lifting heavy loads or working on uneven ground, the CAT 279C may be the best option due to its added weight and stability. On the other hand, if you need a machine with slightly more lift height, a better suspension system, and a higher rated operating capacity, the Bobcat TL250 might be the ideal choice.
Both machines are well-regarded in the industry and have a strong reputation for reliability. By understanding the nuances between the two, you can make a more informed decision based on your specific needs, ensuring you get the most out of your investment.