Bobcat S630 vs. CAT 246D: A Comprehensive Comparison

[MikePhua]

When it comes to skid steer loaders, two of the most recognized names in the industry are Bobcat and Caterpillar (CAT). Both the Bobcat S630 and the CAT 246D are versatile, powerful machines designed for a variety of construction, landscaping, and agriculture tasks. In this article, we compare these two skid steers to help you determine which one suits your needs best.
Engine and Power
Both the Bobcat S630 and the CAT 246D are equipped with powerful engines, but there are key differences in their specifications:

• Bobcat S630: Powered by a 74.3 horsepower turbocharged diesel engine, the Bobcat S630 provides excellent power for demanding tasks. The engine is well-regarded for its fuel efficiency and strong performance, especially for lifting and digging.
  
• CAT 246D: The CAT 246D features a 74.3 horsepower engine as well. Both machines offer the same horsepower, but CAT's engine is designed to provide a balance between power and fuel economy, with a reputation for low operating costs and durability.
  

Both machines are powered by diesel engines, offering reliability and efficiency, making them well-suited for both short and long working hours in tough conditions.
Hydraulic Performance
Hydraulic performance is one of the key factors for any skid steer, as it affects the machine's lifting ability and overall work performance. Both the Bobcat S630 and CAT 246D feature excellent hydraulic systems.

• Bobcat S630: The S630 comes with a high-flow hydraulic system, allowing it to handle demanding attachments such as augers, mulchers, and snow blowers. The hydraulic flow rate is around 23.5 gpm (gallons per minute), providing strong lifting capacity and attachment support.
  
• CAT 246D: Similarly, the CAT 246D features a high-flow hydraulic system, with a hydraulic flow rate of 24.2 gpm, slightly surpassing the Bobcat in hydraulic flow capacity. This slight difference gives the CAT 246D an edge when using higher-demand attachments that require more flow.
  

Both machines offer auxiliary hydraulic capabilities, but the CAT 246D has a slight advantage in hydraulic flow.
Lift Capacity and Reach
When it comes to lifting heavy loads, both machines are capable, but there are subtle differences in their performance.

• Bobcat S630: With a rated operating capacity of 2,400 lbs, the Bobcat S630 provides excellent lifting power. Its lift path design also allows for great reach, making it ideal for handling large loads or working in tight spaces.
  
• CAT 246D: The CAT 246D offers a 2,400 lbs rated operating capacity as well, matching the Bobcat in lifting power. However, CAT's vertical lift design enhances the loader’s reach and ability to lift high into truck beds or bins, which is crucial for unloading materials efficiently.
  

Both skid steers offer similar rated operating capacities, but the CAT 246D might be preferred for jobs requiring higher reach or loading in confined spaces due to its vertical lift.
Operator Comfort and Controls
Operator comfort is critical for long hours of operation. Both the Bobcat S630 and CAT 246D have made significant strides in enhancing operator comfort.

• Bobcat S630: The Bobcat S630 features a spacious cab with great visibility, making it easy for operators to work safely and efficiently. The controls are responsive, and the ride is smooth thanks to its adjustable suspension. The joystick controls are intuitive and easy to operate.
  
• CAT 246D: The CAT 246D offers an equally comfortable operator environment, with a well-designed, ergonomic cab. The ride quality is superior with its advanced suspension system, and the adjustable seat helps reduce operator fatigue. The control system is highly intuitive, with multiple control options available, including optional joystick steering.
  

Both machines offer excellent ergonomics, but the CAT 246D stands out for its superior suspension system, which reduces vibrations and improves ride comfort, particularly on uneven surfaces.
Maneuverability and Versatility
Maneuverability is a crucial aspect of any skid steer loader, especially in tight spaces. Both machines offer impressive maneuverability, but there are some differences.

• Bobcat S630: With its compact size and radius lift path, the Bobcat S630 excels in confined workspaces. The machine is easy to maneuver and can turn on a dime, making it perfect for urban construction sites or landscaping tasks.
  
• CAT 246D: The CAT 246D features vertical lift capability, allowing it to work efficiently in tighter spaces as well. Its radial lift provides excellent horizontal reach and superior lifting ability at lower heights, while also delivering powerful breakout force for digging tasks.
  

Both machines are highly maneuverable, but the Bobcat S630 may be slightly more suited to tight, confined work areas due to its radius lift path.
Maintenance and Durability
Both Bobcat and Caterpillar have reputations for manufacturing durable machines, but the ease of maintenance can vary.

• Bobcat S630: Bobcat machines are known for their easy-to-access maintenance points. The S630 features a tilt-up cab, which makes it easy to reach important components for service and repairs. Routine maintenance tasks like changing oil, filters, and checking fluid levels are straightforward.
  
• CAT 246D: The CAT 246D offers similar maintenance accessibility, with tilt-up cab design and easily reachable service points. The machine’s Durabreak™ brake system requires less frequent maintenance, which can reduce downtime.
  

Both machines have great maintenance accessibility, but the CAT 246D might offer a slight advantage in terms of overall reliability and lower service intervals.
Conclusion
When comparing the Bobcat S630 and the CAT 246D, both machines offer excellent performance, strong lifting capacities, and operator comfort. The Bobcat S630 excels in maneuverability, particularly in tight spaces, while the CAT 246D offers superior hydraulic flow, enhanced lifting reach, and a smoother ride due to its suspension system.
If hydraulic performance, lifting reach, and ride comfort are your priorities, the CAT 246D might be the better choice. However, if you need a more compact machine with excellent maneuverability in confined spaces, the Bobcat S630 would likely suit your needs best.
Ultimately, both machines are highly capable, and the decision will depend on the specific requirements of your job site and personal preferences.