Yesterday, 03:25 PM
The Temptation of Fuel Stretching
With diesel prices fluctuating and waste oil accumulating in shops and yards, many operators have considered blending used engine or hydraulic oil into diesel fuel as a cost-saving measure. The idea seems simple: reduce disposal costs and stretch fuel supplies. However, the practice is fraught with mechanical, environmental, and legal risks that often outweigh the perceived benefits.
Historically, during fuel shortages in the 1970s, some rural operators experimented with mixing waste oil into diesel to keep their machines running. Anecdotes from logging camps in Georgia and mining operations in Wyoming suggest that while some engines tolerated the mix, others suffered from severe sludge buildup, clogged filters, and premature wear.
Terminology Note
Modern diesel engines, especially those with electronic fuel injection systems, are highly sensitive to fuel quality. These systems operate at pressures exceeding 30,000 psi and rely on precise viscosity and lubricity parameters. Introducing waste oil—even in small amounts—can disrupt injector timing, clog particulate filters, and trigger fault codes in the ECU (Engine Control Unit).
Older mechanical injection systems, like those found in pre-1990 Caterpillar D-series dozers, were more forgiving. These machines were designed to run on less-refined diesel and could tolerate minor contamination. However, even these engines were never intended to burn unfiltered waste oil.
A 2022 study by a Canadian fleet maintenance firm found that engines running a 5% waste oil blend experienced a 60% increase in fuel filter replacements and a 15% drop in fuel efficiency over six months.
Filtering and Processing Requirements
To make waste oil usable as a fuel additive, it must be thoroughly filtered. This involves:
A mining operation in Western Australia developed a proprietary filtration system that allowed them to reuse 1,000 liters of waste oil monthly in their haul trucks. However, the system cost over $50,000 to install and required constant monitoring.
Legal and Environmental Considerations
In many jurisdictions, burning waste oil in engines is illegal due to emissions regulations. ULSD mandates and clean air laws prohibit the use of high-sulfur or contaminated fuels. Violators may face fines, equipment seizure, or loss of operating licenses.
In California, for example, using waste oil as a fuel additive without proper certification can result in penalties exceeding $10,000 per incident. The state classifies such practices as environmental violations due to the release of heavy metals and unburned hydrocarbons.
Moreover, improper disposal of waste oil—such as dumping or burning in open pits—can contaminate soil and groundwater. The EPA estimates that one gallon of waste oil can pollute up to one million gallons of drinking water.
Alternative Uses for Waste Oil
Instead of blending with diesel, waste oil can be repurposed safely and legally:
Manufacturer Warnings and Historical Lessons
Caterpillar, one of the world’s leading heavy equipment manufacturers, has long emphasized fuel cleanliness. Fuel caps on older models like the 1943 D4-2T were embossed with the phrase “Buy Clean Fuel.” This was not just marketing—it was a response to widespread engine failures caused by contaminated fuel during the early diesel era.
In the 1930s, diesel fuel was stored in open drums and cans, often exposed to rain and dust. Operators sometimes added asphalt or kerosene to their tanks, believing that “Cats will burn anything.” While the engines ran, they suffered from injector erosion, piston scoring, and shortened lifespans.
Today’s engines are even less tolerant. With tighter tolerances and emissions controls, the margin for error is slim. Manufacturers like Cummins, Volvo, and Komatsu explicitly prohibit the use of waste oil blends in their warranty terms.
Conclusion
While the idea of mixing used oil with diesel fuel may seem economically appealing, the risks to engine health, legal compliance, and environmental safety are substantial. Modern diesel systems demand clean, consistent fuel to operate efficiently and meet emissions standards. For most operators, the best solution is to recycle waste oil through certified channels or repurpose it for heating. Stretching fuel supplies with contaminated oil may save pennies today but could cost thousands in repairs and fines tomorrow. The mantra remains valid: buy clean fuel, keep it clean, and treat waste oil as a resource—not a shortcut.
With diesel prices fluctuating and waste oil accumulating in shops and yards, many operators have considered blending used engine or hydraulic oil into diesel fuel as a cost-saving measure. The idea seems simple: reduce disposal costs and stretch fuel supplies. However, the practice is fraught with mechanical, environmental, and legal risks that often outweigh the perceived benefits.
Historically, during fuel shortages in the 1970s, some rural operators experimented with mixing waste oil into diesel to keep their machines running. Anecdotes from logging camps in Georgia and mining operations in Wyoming suggest that while some engines tolerated the mix, others suffered from severe sludge buildup, clogged filters, and premature wear.
Terminology Note
- Waste Oil: Used lubricants drained from engines, hydraulics, or transmissions. Contains contaminants like soot, water, acids, and metal particles.
- Cetane Number: A measure of diesel fuel’s ignition quality. Higher cetane means better combustion.
- BTU (British Thermal Unit): A unit of energy. Higher BTU content indicates more energy per volume of fuel.
- ULSD (Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel): Modern diesel fuel with reduced sulfur content to meet emissions standards.
Modern diesel engines, especially those with electronic fuel injection systems, are highly sensitive to fuel quality. These systems operate at pressures exceeding 30,000 psi and rely on precise viscosity and lubricity parameters. Introducing waste oil—even in small amounts—can disrupt injector timing, clog particulate filters, and trigger fault codes in the ECU (Engine Control Unit).
Older mechanical injection systems, like those found in pre-1990 Caterpillar D-series dozers, were more forgiving. These machines were designed to run on less-refined diesel and could tolerate minor contamination. However, even these engines were never intended to burn unfiltered waste oil.
A 2022 study by a Canadian fleet maintenance firm found that engines running a 5% waste oil blend experienced a 60% increase in fuel filter replacements and a 15% drop in fuel efficiency over six months.
Filtering and Processing Requirements
To make waste oil usable as a fuel additive, it must be thoroughly filtered. This involves:
- Removing water via centrifuge or settling tanks
- Filtering out carbon and metal particles using multi-stage filters
- Neutralizing acids with chemical additives
- Heating the oil to reduce viscosity before blending
A mining operation in Western Australia developed a proprietary filtration system that allowed them to reuse 1,000 liters of waste oil monthly in their haul trucks. However, the system cost over $50,000 to install and required constant monitoring.
Legal and Environmental Considerations
In many jurisdictions, burning waste oil in engines is illegal due to emissions regulations. ULSD mandates and clean air laws prohibit the use of high-sulfur or contaminated fuels. Violators may face fines, equipment seizure, or loss of operating licenses.
In California, for example, using waste oil as a fuel additive without proper certification can result in penalties exceeding $10,000 per incident. The state classifies such practices as environmental violations due to the release of heavy metals and unburned hydrocarbons.
Moreover, improper disposal of waste oil—such as dumping or burning in open pits—can contaminate soil and groundwater. The EPA estimates that one gallon of waste oil can pollute up to one million gallons of drinking water.
Alternative Uses for Waste Oil
Instead of blending with diesel, waste oil can be repurposed safely and legally:
- Shop Heating: Waste oil furnaces can burn used oil to heat garages and workshops. These systems require certification and regular cleaning but offer significant savings in cold climates.
- Dust Suppression: In the past, some rural roads were treated with waste oil to reduce dust. This practice is now banned in most regions due to environmental concerns.
- Recycling Services: Many companies collect and reprocess waste oil into bunker fuel for ships or industrial burners. However, the market is shrinking as vessels transition to cleaner fuels.
Manufacturer Warnings and Historical Lessons
Caterpillar, one of the world’s leading heavy equipment manufacturers, has long emphasized fuel cleanliness. Fuel caps on older models like the 1943 D4-2T were embossed with the phrase “Buy Clean Fuel.” This was not just marketing—it was a response to widespread engine failures caused by contaminated fuel during the early diesel era.
In the 1930s, diesel fuel was stored in open drums and cans, often exposed to rain and dust. Operators sometimes added asphalt or kerosene to their tanks, believing that “Cats will burn anything.” While the engines ran, they suffered from injector erosion, piston scoring, and shortened lifespans.
Today’s engines are even less tolerant. With tighter tolerances and emissions controls, the margin for error is slim. Manufacturers like Cummins, Volvo, and Komatsu explicitly prohibit the use of waste oil blends in their warranty terms.
Conclusion
While the idea of mixing used oil with diesel fuel may seem economically appealing, the risks to engine health, legal compliance, and environmental safety are substantial. Modern diesel systems demand clean, consistent fuel to operate efficiently and meet emissions standards. For most operators, the best solution is to recycle waste oil through certified channels or repurpose it for heating. Stretching fuel supplies with contaminated oil may save pennies today but could cost thousands in repairs and fines tomorrow. The mantra remains valid: buy clean fuel, keep it clean, and treat waste oil as a resource—not a shortcut.
