Yesterday, 02:34 PM
Why a Self-Lifting Boom Happens
Sometimes a midi (mid-size) excavator seems to “think for itself”: the boom slowly rises — even when the operator releases the controls. This phenomenon is often called “boom creep” or “boom float.” It’s not magic but usually a sign of an internal hydraulic imbalance or mechanical oversight. The issue stems from the fact that when the arm’s hydraulic cylinder is held under load (e.g. the arm is supporting weight), any drop or backflow in the hydraulic circuit — or small leaks — can slowly let fluid build pressure behind the piston, lifting the boom.
Excavators have long relied on hydraulic cylinders with check valves, counterbalance valves, or load-holding valves to prevent unintended motion. These valves are supposed to keep the boom from drifting when controls are neutral. If they fail, or if oil flows back through worn seals under pressure, the boom can drift upward. This is especially common in older machines or heavy-duty “midi” class excavators that see constant cycling and heavy stress.
Common Causes of Boom Drift
Several mechanical or hydraulic root causes can trigger the “boom keeps lifting” behavior:
Why It Matters and the Dangers
A drifting boom isn’t just an annoyance — it’s a serious safety risk. If the boom lifts unexpectedly while someone is working under it, or while shifting loads, the uncontrolled movement can cause injury, load drop, or machine instability.
Moreover, it’s a hazard for precision tasks: digging, grading, or working near pipelines. A few centimeters of unexpected boom movement can ruin accuracy, damage underground utilities, or lead to rework.
Inspection and Troubleshooting Steps
If you notice boom float, follow a methodical inspection plan:
Based on the root cause identified, use one of these approaches:
Midi excavators are a compromise between compact machines and full-size heavy excavators. They often feature enough hydraulic power for demanding tasks, yet use simpler valve and cylinder designs for cost and maintenance ease. Over decades, these designs have aged and many units undergo constant heavy use — digging hard soil, loading trucks, working in dusty or muddy conditions. This wear-and-tear accelerates seal and valve degradation.
Manufacturers originally allowed modest hydraulic creep tolerances, assuming regular maintenance. But many owners operate machines in remote sites where maintenance intervals stretch, hydraulic oil degrades, and seals erode — conditions perfect for downtime.
Real-World Examples & Lessons Learned
One contractor in South America replaced all boom seals and cleaned valves on a mid-size excavator after repeated boom creep incidents under 2-ton bucket loads. After repair, they logged 1,200 hours with no recurrence. They noted that before repair fuel consumption and idle time had increased, suggesting the machine was working harder to compensate for hydraulic inefficiency.
Another small-town municipality had an older excavator whose boom lifted slowly overnight in the parked, neutral position. No load was attached — yet the boom rose by 5 cm over six hours. Inspection revealed pilot-line degradation and valve spring fatigue; after replacing pilot hoses and rebuilding the valve block, the boom held firmly even under full hydraulic pressure.
Maintenance Practices to Prevent Future Issues
To minimize risk of unintended boom lifting, adopt a maintenance routine:
When a midi excavator’s boom keeps lifting, it is seldom a “stupid question” — but a clear warning. The problem typically lies in worn seals, failing valves, or degraded oil/contamination. By understanding hydraulic pump and valve design (especially load-holding vs float mechanisms), operators and mechanics can locate, fix, and prevent unintended boom movement. Regular inspection, quality hydraulic fluid, correct parts and cautious operation will keep the boom where it should stay — under controlled command, not creeping on its own.
Sometimes a midi (mid-size) excavator seems to “think for itself”: the boom slowly rises — even when the operator releases the controls. This phenomenon is often called “boom creep” or “boom float.” It’s not magic but usually a sign of an internal hydraulic imbalance or mechanical oversight. The issue stems from the fact that when the arm’s hydraulic cylinder is held under load (e.g. the arm is supporting weight), any drop or backflow in the hydraulic circuit — or small leaks — can slowly let fluid build pressure behind the piston, lifting the boom.
Excavators have long relied on hydraulic cylinders with check valves, counterbalance valves, or load-holding valves to prevent unintended motion. These valves are supposed to keep the boom from drifting when controls are neutral. If they fail, or if oil flows back through worn seals under pressure, the boom can drift upward. This is especially common in older machines or heavy-duty “midi” class excavators that see constant cycling and heavy stress.
Common Causes of Boom Drift
Several mechanical or hydraulic root causes can trigger the “boom keeps lifting” behavior:
- Worn or leaking boom cylinder seals — internal seals may no longer hold pressure perfectly.
- Faulty or dirty counterbalance / load-holding valve — these valves prevent backflow under load; if blocked or worn, they fail to lock.
- Incorrect hydraulic oil viscosity or contamination — thin or dirty oil may seep past seals.
- Overpressurized hydraulic system or improper valve settings — can force fluid past holding valves.
- Misadjusted relief valves or pilot lines — allowing creeping pressure buildup even when controls are in neutral.
Why It Matters and the Dangers
A drifting boom isn’t just an annoyance — it’s a serious safety risk. If the boom lifts unexpectedly while someone is working under it, or while shifting loads, the uncontrolled movement can cause injury, load drop, or machine instability.
Moreover, it’s a hazard for precision tasks: digging, grading, or working near pipelines. A few centimeters of unexpected boom movement can ruin accuracy, damage underground utilities, or lead to rework.
Inspection and Troubleshooting Steps
If you notice boom float, follow a methodical inspection plan:
- Park the machine on level ground, put the boom in a neutral “rest” position. Watch for movement over 5–10 minutes.
- If boom rises, try lightly pressing the boom lever down (as if to lower it) — if it drifts even then, cylinder seals are suspect.
- Drain and inspect hydraulic oil condition and level — contamination or incorrect viscosity reduces seal integrity.
- Check the counterbalance or load-holding valve — these valves are usually inside the main control valve bank; ensure they move freely, are not rusted or blocked by sludge.
- Examine relief valve settings and pilot lines — incorrect settings sometimes cause unintended leak paths or pressure bleedback.
Based on the root cause identified, use one of these approaches:
- Replace cylinder worn seals — use OEM or high-grade aftermarket kits; always test under load after replacement.
- Clean or rebuild the counterbalance / load-holding valve — flush out sludge, replace valve spools or springs if needed.
- Use correct hydraulic oil grade, and ensure regular fluid and filter changes — contamination is a leading cause of seal failure.
- After repair, conduct a load-holding test: extend boom, leave bucket empty, raise boom, and leave for several hours; no drift should occur.
- For heavy-duty or long-term use, consider installing external check valves as a retrofit for added safety.
Midi excavators are a compromise between compact machines and full-size heavy excavators. They often feature enough hydraulic power for demanding tasks, yet use simpler valve and cylinder designs for cost and maintenance ease. Over decades, these designs have aged and many units undergo constant heavy use — digging hard soil, loading trucks, working in dusty or muddy conditions. This wear-and-tear accelerates seal and valve degradation.
Manufacturers originally allowed modest hydraulic creep tolerances, assuming regular maintenance. But many owners operate machines in remote sites where maintenance intervals stretch, hydraulic oil degrades, and seals erode — conditions perfect for downtime.
Real-World Examples & Lessons Learned
One contractor in South America replaced all boom seals and cleaned valves on a mid-size excavator after repeated boom creep incidents under 2-ton bucket loads. After repair, they logged 1,200 hours with no recurrence. They noted that before repair fuel consumption and idle time had increased, suggesting the machine was working harder to compensate for hydraulic inefficiency.
Another small-town municipality had an older excavator whose boom lifted slowly overnight in the parked, neutral position. No load was attached — yet the boom rose by 5 cm over six hours. Inspection revealed pilot-line degradation and valve spring fatigue; after replacing pilot hoses and rebuilding the valve block, the boom held firmly even under full hydraulic pressure.
Maintenance Practices to Prevent Future Issues
To minimize risk of unintended boom lifting, adopt a maintenance routine:
- Check hydraulic fluid every 100 hours — look for discoloration, metallic particles, or smell (overheating).
- Perform seal and valve inspection every 500–800 hours depending on workload and environment.
- Use clean hydraulic oil and certified filter elements, especially in dusty or muddy conditions.
- After heavy work days, lower the boom fully and let it rest — this avoids continuous pressure on seals, prolonging life.
- Document maintenance and unusual behavior — logs help trace gradual wear before failure.
When a midi excavator’s boom keeps lifting, it is seldom a “stupid question” — but a clear warning. The problem typically lies in worn seals, failing valves, or degraded oil/contamination. By understanding hydraulic pump and valve design (especially load-holding vs float mechanisms), operators and mechanics can locate, fix, and prevent unintended boom movement. Regular inspection, quality hydraulic fluid, correct parts and cautious operation will keep the boom where it should stay — under controlled command, not creeping on its own.
