Welcome, Guest |
You have to register before you can post on our site.
|
Forum Statistics |
» Members: 43
» Latest member: Bob808
» Forum threads: 17,245
» Forum posts: 17,247
Full Statistics
|
Online Users |
There are currently 167 online users. » 1 Member(s) | 163 Guest(s) Bing, Facebook, Google, MikePhua
|
|
|
Caterpillar 320D Excavator: A User Review and Performance Evaluation |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 05:16 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
The Caterpillar 320D Excavator is one of the standout models in Caterpillar's lineup, known for its robustness and reliability. In this article, we explore the experiences of a seasoned user, Mr. Sun Xuliang (referred to as Xiao Sun), an experienced excavator operator from Ningxia. With over 7 years of operating experience, Xiao Sun has been an active member in the industry, sharing his insights and contributions online, and has helped others, like a senior member from Ningxia, in selecting the Caterpillar 320D. This review reflects his firsthand experience with the 320D excavator.
1. User Background
Xiao Sun, born in the 1980s, works as an excavator operator for a construction company under the Shangling Group in Ningxia, primarily engaged in water conservancy, construction, and road projects. He started his career in excavation after completing middle school and has accumulated over 7 years of operating experience. Before working with the Caterpillar 320D, Xiao Sun operated the company’s Hitachi ZX230-1 excavator. His company is one of the major players in the region, with a fleet of heavy machinery including excavators, loaders, dump trucks, and rollers. Xiao Sun is highly regarded by his superiors due to his skill and experience.
2. Purchase Information
Due to increased project demands, the company decided to purchase a new excavator in early 2010. After reviewing several models, including the Komatsu PC240-8 and the Caterpillar 320D, Xiao Sun was tasked with selecting the final choice. After testing the machines and consulting with his peers, Xiao Sun opted for the Caterpillar 320D, praising its durability, precision handling, and high reliability. On March 15, 2010, Xiao Sun purchased the Caterpillar 320D from the local Caterpillar dealer, Yichu Mingtong, for 1.13 million RMB, paying the full amount upfront. The purchase also included 6,000 RMB worth of accessories.
3. Operator Information
Since the purchase, Xiao Sun has personally operated the 320D, though he occasionally assigns some simple tasks to his apprentice. As evidenced by his online posts, Xiao Sun takes great care of the machine and treats it as his own. However, there was an incident where his apprentice accidentally drove the excavator into a trench, which Xiao Sun found particularly upsetting.
4. Work Conditions
Xiao Sun’s company was contracted for a road construction project, where the 320D was used for tasks such as leveling roads, repairing slopes, and soil excavation. The work primarily involved soil-related tasks with no stone present. Some areas had soft sandy soil, while others featured firmer ground conditions.
5. Work Efficiency
Given that the work mainly involved soil excavation, the 320D proved to be highly efficient. Xiao Sun reported that compared to the Hitachi ZX230-1 and other similar models, the Caterpillar 320D outperformed the others in terms of speed, digging force, and precision in handling. The machine’s impressive capabilities were particularly evident in various earthmoving tasks, where its performance exceeded expectations.
6. Fuel Consumption
In normal conditions, using 7-8 throttle levels, the fuel consumption of the 320D is around 18 liters per hour. When the job requires full throttle, the consumption increases to 23 liters per hour. This fuel consumption is considered above average for excavators in this class, though it is still relatively reasonable given the machine's size and power.
7. Product Performance and Issues
Engine:
Since the purchase, the engine has had no issues and runs smoothly.
Hydraulic System:
The hydraulic system has also performed without any problems, ensuring reliable and consistent operation.
Other Issues:
The only issue reported by Xiao Sun was a minor one – the lock on the tool box broke, preventing the key from fitting into the lock. After consulting with the dealer, Xiao Sun learned that replacing the lock assembly would cost over 1,000 RMB, so the company decided to keep using the lock as is. Additionally, Xiao Sun mentioned that the seat was uncomfortable, with insufficient support for the back. He also expressed dissatisfaction with the paint quality on the boom and arm, as the coating appeared rough, with noticeable weld marks.
8. Dealer and Service
Xiao Sun expressed satisfaction with the service provided by Yichu Mingtong, the local Caterpillar dealer. They have been responsive to maintenance needs and have kept the machine in good condition with timely servicing.
9. Spare Parts
When discussing the spare parts for the Caterpillar 320D, Xiao Sun remarked that the parts were significantly more expensive than those of other brands. For example, a barrel of engine oil for the 320D was nearly 200 RMB more expensive than that for the Hitachi excavator he previously operated, and the filters were also pricier. While the company has the financial resources to handle the costs, Xiao Sun noted that many individual users find these prices prohibitive. In online forums, several Caterpillar owners have expressed concerns about the high cost of spare parts, which could deter budget-conscious customers from choosing the brand.
10. Conclusion
The Caterpillar 320D is undoubtedly one of the most popular and reliable models in Caterpillar’s excavator range. Since its introduction in 2006, the 320D has frequently been the top-selling excavator in the Chinese market, known for its durability, versatility, and outstanding performance in both heavy and light tasks. From Xiao Sun’s experience, the 320D is well-suited for tasks like roadwork and earthmoving, offering high efficiency and low failure rates. However, the high cost of spare parts remains a significant drawback, especially for individual users or those with tight budgets. Despite this, the 320D continues to be a top choice for large companies and well-funded individual users who prioritize reliability and performance over operational costs.
|
|
|
SANY SY215C-8 Excavator: User Experience and Performance Review |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 04:58 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
The SANY SY215C-8 is one of the best-selling models among domestic excavators and enjoys a high reputation in the market. In this article, we share the experience of Mr. Gao, a seasoned user from Liaoning Province (Member OO8), who has been using this model for his business. This report serves as a representative feedback of the SANY SY215C-8, a widely popular model in the domestic excavator market.
1. User Background
Mr. Gao, born in the 1970s, is from Liaoyang, Liaoning. He is a seasoned construction machinery user with extensive experience. Five years ago, he entered the construction machinery rental business and previously purchased a Longgong ZL50C and a XGMA 951 loader. The SANY SY215C-8 is the first excavator he bought for his own use. Mr. Gao conducted extensive research before choosing this model and found it to be the best option for his needs.
2. Purchase Information
In April 2010, Mr. Gao purchased the SANY SY215C-8 through financing lease from the SANY dealer, Sanjun Engineering Machinery Co., Ltd., in Liaoning. The total price was 840,000 RMB, with a 240,000 RMB down payment and the remainder financed over 24 months, with monthly payments of 29,000 RMB. As part of the deal, he received 10,000 RMB worth of free accessories. Before making the final decision, Mr. Gao considered several models, including the Hyundai R215-9, Doosan DH225LC-7, and SANY SY215C-8. After a thorough comparison, he chose the SY215C-8 for its superior configuration, including the fully imported Mitsubishi engine and Japanese Kawasaki hydraulic components.
3. Operator Situation
The operator of the SANY SY215C-8 is a young local man from the 1980s who is responsible for both the maintenance and operation of the machine. He is experienced and ensures proper care and operation of the excavator.
4. Work Conditions
After purchasing the machine, Mr. Gao initially used the excavator for around 100 hours of scattered work at home. The machine was then moved to a high-speed railway construction site managed by China Railway 19th Bureau, where it has been used for digging foundation piles and land leveling. The work environment mainly involves soft soil and earthworks.
5. Work Efficiency
The SANY SY215C-8 is praised for its speed and efficiency in the field. Mr. Gao noted that compared to other machines on the same site, such as the Komatsu PC220-8 and Doosan DH225LC-7, the SY215C-8 is slightly faster and more responsive, which makes it popular with the on-site team.
6. Fuel Consumption
Fuel consumption for the SY215C-8 is relatively low for its class. When operating at 7 throttle levels, the fuel consumption is between 12-14 liters per hour. When working at full throttle (10 levels), fuel consumption rises to around 18 liters per hour. Overall, the fuel efficiency of the SY215C-8 is competitive compared to similar models in its category, making it a cost-effective choice for operators.
7. Product Performance and Issues
Engine:
The engine has been running smoothly for over 1400 hours without any issues. The only downside noted by Mr. Gao is the engine noise, which is louder than that of the Doosan DH225LC-7, especially when working alongside it.
Hydraulic System:
The hydraulic system has not encountered any problems and continues to perform reliably.
Other Issues:
The only issue Mr. Gao has faced is an accident where the air conditioning condenser was damaged by the operator. This was a minor incident and Mr. Gao managed to repair it himself. Overall, the machine has had no major mechanical failures or quality issues, with over 1400 hours of use.
8. Dealer and Service
Mr. Gao is very satisfied with the service provided by SANY’s local dealer, Sanjun Engineering Machinery Co., Ltd. He has found their response times to be fast and their service support reliable. In his own words, “The service is quick, and they respond to any inquiries promptly.”
9. Spare Parts and Maintenance
Mr. Gao mentioned that he has mostly dealt with maintenance parts, which are relatively expensive. While the parts are of high quality, especially considering the imported Japanese components, he expressed a desire for slightly lower prices to help reduce operating costs for users.
10. Conclusion
Overall, Mr. Gao is highly satisfied with the performance of the SANY SY215C-8. Since its purchase, the excavator has performed well without any major failures related to the machine's quality. It is particularly well-suited for earthworks, offering excellent fuel efficiency and fast operation. The service from the dealer has also been commendable, providing a solid support system for the machine. Mr. Gao is optimistic about the next few thousand hours of operation, hoping the excavator will continue to perform well and generate profits for his business.
|
|
|
Caterpillar 307D Excavator: User Experience and Performance Review |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 04:54 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
The Caterpillar 307D, a 7-ton excavator, is a fully imported model made in Japan. As the first of its kind in Hubei Province, it has become a significant piece of machinery for local construction projects. This article shares the experience of a user, referred to as "Xiao Hu," who transitioned from an excavator operator to an owner. His experience with the 307D provides valuable insight into its performance and reliability in real-world conditions.
1. User Background
Xiao Hu, born in 1986, is a typical example of someone who transitioned from being an excavator operator to becoming an owner. Before purchasing the Caterpillar 307D, Xiao Hu had nearly five years of hands-on experience operating excavators, primarily working for his brother-in-law. As the infrastructure development in his local area started to grow, Xiao Hu saved up enough money to invest in his own excavator and start his own business.
2. Purchase Information
On January 15, 2010, Xiao Hu purchased the Caterpillar 307D from the Hubei branch of Lixingxing, a local dealer. The machine cost 510,000 yuan, with an additional insurance fee of 19,700 yuan. Xiao Hu made a down payment of 120,000 yuan and financed the rest over three years. Initially, he considered several options, including the Caterpillar 307D, the Hitachi ZX70 (fully imported), and the Komatsu PC60-7. After carefully weighing the price, payment terms, and the reputation for quality and performance, Xiao Hu chose the Caterpillar 307D for its superior performance and reliability.
3. Operator Situation
As an experienced excavator operator, Xiao Hu personally operates the machine, especially in the early stages of his business when cost efficiency was crucial. His hands-on approach allows him to better manage the equipment and ensure smooth operations.
4. Work Conditions
Xiao Hu primarily works in the Jianghan Plain area of Hubei, where his tasks mostly involve foundation digging, leveling, and land reclamation projects for agricultural water conservancy. These types of projects require high efficiency and precision, making the Caterpillar 307D a reliable choice for the work at hand.
5. Work Efficiency
The Caterpillar 307D impresses with its fast rotation and arm-lifting actions, which are noticeably quicker than other excavators of the same class working on the same job site. Xiao Hu’s friend, who operates a Caterpillar 307C, also agrees that the 307D performs significantly faster than its predecessor. This improved speed and efficiency make it well-suited for the tasks at hand.
6. Fuel Consumption
In terms of fuel consumption, the 307D is relatively efficient. When operating with the air conditioning on and the throttle set to 5, the machine consumes around 5.9 liters of fuel per hour. With local diesel priced at 6.25 yuan per liter, this equates to approximately 37 yuan per hour. Xiao Hu considers this fuel consumption to be average compared to other excavators in its class. For reference, the Hitachi ZX70, when using the economy mode, consumes about 4 yuan less per hour than the 307D, but if the power mode is used, its fuel consumption exceeds that of the 307D by a significant margin.
7. Product Performance and Issues
Engine:
The engine of the Caterpillar 307D has performed flawlessly with no issues to report.
Hydraulic System:
The hydraulic system has also shown no problems, and it continues to operate smoothly.
Other Issues:
In the first 1,000 hours of operation, Xiao Hu has not encountered any mechanical failures or malfunctions, which reflects the overall reliability of the machine.
8. Dealer and Customer Service
Xiao Hu is very satisfied with the service from Lixingxing, the authorized dealer. Since purchasing the 307D, the dealer has provided quick and efficient service, responding to any queries or issues promptly. Xiao Hu recalls how, in a post about his first maintenance experience, he praised the dealer's fast response, noting that whenever he called, the dealer's team would arrive on the same day.
9. Spare Parts and Maintenance
As the first Caterpillar 307D in Hubei Province, Xiao Hu was offered a special promotion by Lixingxing, which included free maintenance for the first 1,500 hours. During this period, he only needed to purchase one air filter for 218 yuan. Xiao Hu finds the spare parts prices for the 307D to be reasonable, especially compared to many domestic brands, which can sometimes be more expensive. He is content with the cost of maintenance and spare parts, which he believes are affordable for a machine of this quality.
10. Conclusion
The Caterpillar 307D has proven to be an excellent investment for Xiao Hu, becoming his most valuable asset. The machine’s performance, coupled with the reliable service from the dealer, has made Xiao Hu confident in its ability to meet his needs for the long term. With a solid reputation in the 7-ton excavator category, the Caterpillar 307D continues to exceed expectations, and Xiao Hu looks forward to the next 1,000 hours of operation. His success with this machine is a testament to its durability and efficiency, and he hopes it will soon provide him with the "first pot of gold" from his business, helping him grow his excavator operations further.
|
|
|
Caterpillar 336DL Excavator User Review and Experience |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 04:52 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
The Caterpillar 336DL is a highly regarded excavator known for its robust performance and reliability. In this article, we will provide a detailed account of its performance, fuel consumption, work efficiency, and other aspects based on real-world usage.
1. Initial Purchase and Selection
In 2004, Qiu Yinuo (the user) began his career in the excavation industry, purchasing a second-hand Hitachi EX200 excavator for a brick factory. Over the years, he gained significant experience with various excavators, focusing on quality, performance, control, and comfort. In November 2009, Qiu purchased the Caterpillar 336DL for 2.05 million yuan from Weister in Liaoning. He carefully considered his options and compared the Caterpillar 336DL with other models like the Komatsu PC350-7. Due to the limited availability of the PC350-7 in China and the potential difficulty in finding parts and service, he opted for the more common Caterpillar 336DL, a popular model in local mining operations.
2. Operators and Work Environment
The 336DL is operated by two local 80s-generation machine operators who alternate shifts. Being an experienced excavator operator himself, Qiu pays great attention to the cleanliness and comfort of the cabin. He believes a clean and comfortable working environment is critical for both safety and work efficiency. As a result, the cabin of the 336DL is often praised for its tidiness by others who have seen it.
3. Work Conditions and Efficiency
After purchasing the 336DL, Qiu sent it to a nearby quarry for work, where it primarily handles hard crushed stone produced by explosive blasting. Other mining machines working in the same area include Komatsu PC360 and Hitachi ZX330-3, both of which are also 30-ton class machines.
According to Qiu, the 336DL is equipped with two bucket options: a 1.62 cubic meter rock bucket and a 1.87 cubic meter standard bucket. The 336DL shows clear advantages in work efficiency. For instance, using the 1.62 cubic meter bucket, it typically fills a 40 cubic meter dump truck in just 15 bucket loads, while the Komatsu PC360-7, with a 1.4 cubic meter bucket, struggles to keep up.
Work Efficiency Comparison:- 1.62 cubic meter rock bucket: 15 bucket loads to fill a 40-cubic-meter dump truck.
- Komatsu PC360-7: Struggles with a 1.4 cubic meter bucket, much slower loading times.
- Hitachi ZX330-3: Similar performance to the Komatsu PC360-7.
Additionally, the 336DL excels in digging power. Qiu notes that when other brands' buckets encounter hard rocks, they often fail to penetrate the material fully. However, the 336DL can effortlessly dig all the way through, showcasing its superior digging strength and performance.
4. Handling Performance and Comfort
As a highly experienced operator, Qiu has a deep understanding of excavator handling. He points out that the 336DL’s control precision is unparalleled compared to other brands. When fully loaded with 4 tons of stone and a 2-ton bucket, the 336DL’s swing stop distance is only 6-7 cm, whereas competitors like Komatsu and Hitachi can reach up to 10-20 cm.
Qiu emphasizes that the 336DL provides an excellent "point-and-shoot" control experience, making it extremely precise and easy to maneuver, a quality that stands out among other machines in the same class.
5. Fuel Consumption
In terms of fuel consumption, Qiu notes that the 336DL performs relatively well. When operating in the "E" (economic) mode, the machine averages 28 liters of fuel per hour. In more demanding work conditions, fuel consumption rises to around 32-33 liters per hour. Overall, Qiu finds the 336DL to be quite fuel-efficient compared to other excavators in the same category.
He shared the following fuel consumption data:- 1.64 cubic meter rock bucket in economic mode: 8-9 liters of fuel per hour, with total consumption (including idle time) ranging between 30-33 liters per hour.
- 1.64 cubic meter rock bucket in standard mode: 8 liters of fuel per hour, with total consumption between 33-35 liters per hour.
6. Product Performance and Issues
Qiu has been very impressed with the performance of the Caterpillar 336DL. Since purchasing the machine, he has never needed to call for repairs, which he believes speaks to its reliability. In comparison, other excavators in the same quarry have required repairs.
Regarding engine performance, the 336DL occasionally consumes some oil, requiring an additional 12-13 liters after every 500 hours of operation. Qiu initially raised concerns about the engine oil consumption in a forum post, and after consulting with Weister’s service engineers, he received an explanation. Caterpillar engines are designed to use a special type of oil, and slight oil consumption is considered normal due to the engine’s deep cylinder bore design, which helps extend the engine’s lifespan.
Other Observed Issues:- The engine compartment's handrail fractured, but Qiu had it welded back together.
- The air conditioning intake plastic cover was damaged, a common issue with many excavators, highlighting a design flaw.
- The cabin's front window seal wasn’t tight, leading to dust infiltration during quarry work. Qiu addressed this by applying adhesive to improve the seal.
7. Maintenance and User Tips
To ensure the excavator runs smoothly, Qiu spent 6,000 yuan on a fuel filter machine, which he uses before refueling to remove contaminants from the diesel. This practice significantly reduces the wear on fuel filters, extending their service life. With the filter machine, Qiu now only needs to replace the fuel filter every 1,000 hours instead of the previous 250 hours.
Qiu also added an air pre-filter and a computer anti-theft device to the excavator to enhance its reliability and security.
8. Dealer and Spare Parts
Since the 336DL has been trouble-free, Qiu has never required a service call from the dealer. He handles all maintenance himself, as he is very familiar with the machine’s servicing requirements. However, his interactions with Weister, the dealer, have been positive, with their staff displaying a high level of enthusiasm and professionalism.
Regarding spare parts, most of the components for the 336DL are purchased from Weister, as Qiu believes that original parts are essential for maintaining the equipment’s performance. However, for less critical components like buckets and teeth, he occasionally opts for locally sourced parts that offer good quality at a lower price.
Qiu does acknowledge that some of the Caterpillar parts are expensive, especially compared to competitors like Komatsu and Doosan, whose spare parts are more affordable. This pricing difference often influences customers to choose other brands, as discussed in an article about Doosan's DX300LC-7 excavator.
9. Conclusion
In conclusion, Qiu Yinuo is highly satisfied with the Caterpillar 336DL excavator. He appreciates its high performance, excellent fuel efficiency, and superior handling, all of which make it a reliable workhorse for his quarry operations. Despite the higher cost of spare parts, he believes the long-term benefits of owning this machine far outweigh the initial investment. If the company could adjust the spare parts pricing to be more competitive, Caterpillar could capture an even larger market share. For Qiu, the 336DL has proven to be a valuable asset that combines efficiency and durability, making it an ideal choice for his excavation work.
|
|
|
Doosan DH300LC-7 Excavator User Experience |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 04:28 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
"Old Truck" is a veteran excavator user based in Shandong, with a wealth of experience in the excavation industry. His journey into the world of excavators started back in 2008, when he bought a second-hand Sumitomo SH280 excavator for 160,000 RMB. However, he soon realized that the machine was faulty and had been sold to multiple users who had also been deceived. After consulting with Sumitomo's after-sales service, he was informed that repairing the machine would cost 170,000 RMB. Without hesitation, Old Truck decided to scrap the excavator, selling it as scrap metal for 75,000 RMB to prevent further harm to others. Just 20 days later, he purchased a brand-new Doosan DH300LC-7, marking the beginning of his "excavator journey." In the following two years, he went on to buy two more DH300LC-7s and two Doosan DH215-7s, becoming a true loyal user of the Doosan brand.
Old Truck has been active on engineering machinery forums since May 2009, sharing his experiences and insights. Today, we take a closer look at his first "hero," the Doosan DH300LC-7 excavator.
Purchase Information
Old Truck purchased the Doosan DH300LC-7 in July 2008 from Doosan’s Sichuan distributor—Chengdu Doosan Construction Machinery Co., Ltd. The purchase price was 580,000 RMB, with a down payment of 20% and the balance to be paid off in installments over six months. As of now, the excavator has been in use for 5,700 hours.
Working Conditions
Old Truck's hometown is located in a mountainous region, so most of the work is focused on road construction or site leveling in the mountains, which presents a significant challenge to the excavator. He primarily uses machines that weigh over 25 tons due to the demanding nature of the work.
Work Efficiency
In terms of work efficiency, the DH300LC-7 performs well, although it is slightly slower compared to other popular brands working on the same site. With the addition of a ripper, the DH300LC-7 can excavate over 1,000 cubic meters of material daily. Together with a Komatsu PC220-8 equipped with a breaker and a loader, they are capable of moving more than 300 cubic meters of rubble, valued at over 10,000 RMB per day. This makes the DH300LC-7 an efficient machine in mountain conditions.
Fuel Consumption
While working in the mountains, Old Truck generally uses the excavator at 80% throttle, with a fuel consumption of 28 liters per hour. This is considered quite fuel-efficient for a 300-series excavator.
Product Performance and Issues
Due to the high-intensity stonework, which sometimes requires over 438 hours of continuous operation in a month, the DH300LC-7 has undergone rigorous testing. - Engine: At 1,900 hours of use, the thermostat in the engine failed. After 5,000 hours and regular maintenance, the machine experienced a loss of power. After a diagnosis, the fuel pump was calibrated, and six plungers and six fuel injectors were replaced (totaling 3,900 RMB). The issue was found to be related to the poor quality of fuel at the worksite. After switching to higher-quality fuel, the problem did not recur.
- Hydraulic System: The hydraulic system has not experienced any major issues.
- Other Issues: The original bucket’s tooth plate seat experienced some problems, which were replaced by the dealer. Due to the harsh stone-working conditions, welding repairs and replacements were common, with costs totaling more than 10,000 RMB.
In June 2009, Old Truck purchased a ripper for 10,000 RMB from Chengdu, which significantly improved work efficiency. The ripper proved invaluable on mixed earth and stone worksites, where it helped break up larger stones before the bucket was used to clean up the remaining soil and smaller stones.
Dealer and Service
Old Truck is highly satisfied with the service provided by Doosan’s Sichuan distributor—Chengdu Doosan Construction Machinery Co., Ltd. Being a major Doosan user, he feels that the dealer pays close attention to his needs, and the service is generally prompt and efficient.
Parts and Maintenance
Old Truck also praised the cost of Doosan’s parts, which he finds relatively affordable compared to aftermarket suppliers. For any necessary repairs or replacements, he typically buys parts directly from the dealer, ensuring that he gets genuine components.
Summary
Overall, Old Truck is very satisfied with his Doosan DH300LC-7. The machine is durable, has minimal downtime, and offers great fuel efficiency. The dealer’s after-sales service is also reliable and timely. Over the years, the DH300LC-7 has helped Old Truck generate significant profits from his work in the mountains.
When it comes time to purchase his next excavator, Old Truck is considering either the Doosan DX225LC or the Kobelco SK200-8. While he is very satisfied with his current Doosan machines, he is also intrigued by the speed and fuel efficiency of Kobelco’s excavators. Old Truck’s decision will ultimately be influenced by the strong word-of-mouth reputation of different brands among users in his area.
Through Old Truck’s experience, it is clear that choosing the right equipment, reliable after-sales service, and affordable parts are key factors for success in the excavator business.
|
|
|
Doosan DH55GOLD Excavator Review |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 03:25 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
This time, we interviewed boshan55, a member from Shandong, China. He became a member of Doosan in October 2009, during his study in South Korea. Boshan55 has always been passionate about excavators since childhood, influenced by his family. After returning to China in 2010, he chose the path of entrepreneurship and started excavator leasing in his hometown. His family previously owned a Komatsu PC55MR, and upon his return, he purchased the Doosan DH55GOLD. As a young excavator owner with a background in international study, boshan55's mindset is both sharp and open, which has brought him many opportunities in his business.
Purchase Information
The Doosan DH55GOLD was purchased in early April 2023 from Shandong Yonghong Engineering Machinery Company, an official Doosan dealer. The purchase price was 350,000 CNY, with a 20% down payment and the remaining balance financed over three years. The machine has been in operation for 620 hours since its purchase.
Before deciding, boshan55 also considered an 8-ton Kubota KX185, but due to limited funds and the small size of the Kubota KX155 (a zero-tail swing machine), he opted for the 5-ton Doosan DH55GOLD. He chose Doosan mainly because of its affordability, lower maintenance costs, and availability of affordable spare parts.
However, the purchasing process wasn’t without issues. During the contract signing, the dealer quoted one price, but after signing, the final price increased by 8,000 CNY for an undisclosed guarantee fee. This was never mentioned before signing the contract, which left boshan55 feeling very upset. Additionally, the promised delivery date was delayed by half a month, and the agreed-upon compensation for the delay was never honored. This experience made him lose trust in the dealer.
Work Conditions
The Doosan DH55GOLD is primarily used for small-scale site work such as foundation digging, leveling, and waste cleaning on construction sites. Occasionally, it is also used for road repair and agricultural water conservancy construction.
Efficiency
Although the Doosan DH55GOLD has a relatively fast swing speed, its arm and bucket movements are slower compared to other machines. Boshan55 mentioned that this slower movement often gives the impression that the operator is wasting time. He said, “It’s not about trying to delay time; the machine just doesn’t move fast enough.” When comparing it to his family’s Komatsu PC55-MR, the difference in speed is quite noticeable.
Fuel Consumption
At full throttle, the fuel consumption of the Doosan DH55GOLD is around 4.5 liters per hour. With 500 CNY worth of fuel, the machine can work for about two days.
Product Performance & Issues - Engine: Since it’s a new machine, the only issue so far has been when the machine stalled due to a loose wire. No major problems have occurred.
- Hydraulic System: The hydraulic system is functioning well, without any significant issues.
- Other Issues: There was a problem with greasing the bucket and boom. After contacting after-sales service, it took a week for the technician to come, and even then, the issue wasn't resolved. The grease gun was damaged during the repair, and the technician mentioned that the part was out of stock. To this day, the issue remains unresolved.
Dealer & After-Sales Service
Boshan55 noted that dealing with Shandong Yonghong Engineering Machinery Company was disappointing. From the untrustworthy purchase experience to the lackluster after-sales support, he felt let down by the dealer. The lack of professionalism and attentiveness in after-sales service made him regret his decision.
Spare Parts
Boshan55 highlighted that the cost of Doosan's spare parts is relatively low compared to other brands, which was one of the key reasons for his purchase. However, the ongoing issues with the dealer have made him reconsider the overall experience with the brand.
Conclusion
Overall, while Doosan DH55GOLD has performed well in terms of fuel efficiency and reliability, the poor experience with the dealer has soured boshan55’s opinion of the brand. He mentioned, “If this situation isn’t handled well, not only will I not buy another Doosan machine, but I will also discourage my friends and family from doing so.” In the highly competitive construction machinery market, user reviews play a critical role. It’s crucial for Doosan and its dealers to address customer concerns and resolve any misunderstandings to maintain a good reputation and secure a strong position in the market.
|
|
|
Doosan DH220LC-7 Excavator User Report |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 03:20 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
Doosan is one of the most popular excavator brands in the Chinese market, known for its strong presence and market share. Among its models, the DH220LC-7 is one of the best-selling excavators in Doosan's lineup. In this interview, we feature an experienced excavator user, "Henan Excavator Rental" — Mr. Wang Zipan, who has an impressive background in the construction machinery industry. After his retirement from the armed police force, Mr. Wang entered the industry, starting with wheel loaders. Over the years, his business has grown substantially, and now he operates several pieces of construction machinery. He also holds the regional exclusive agency for a well-known breaker brand (his company is called Henan Jiaozuo Yuyou Engineering Machinery). Mr. Wang is not only expanding his excavator business towards large-scale and professional operations but is also exploring the future direction of the industry in the "post-excavator" era. His insights are valuable for other excavator users.
Purchase Information
The Doosan DH220LC-7 was purchased on September 20, 2006, through a financing plan at a price of 780,000 RMB, with a 20% down payment and the remaining balance to be paid over two years. When deciding on the purchase, Mr. Wang considered three brands: Caterpillar, Volvo, and Doosan. Since this was his first excavator purchase, he was cautious of the risks involved. Ultimately, he chose Doosan, as it offered the lowest price, which allowed for a faster return on investment and lower risk. Later, he also purchased the Doosan DH225LC-7, Caterpillar 320D, and Komatsu PC220-8.
Working Conditions
The DH220LC-7 is used for both earthmoving and rock work. It is commonly employed in road construction projects for earthmoving tasks and is frequently used in the local aluminum mines for rock work.
Work Efficiency
According to Mr. Wang, the DH220LC-7 is a bit slower than other excavators, such as the Caterpillar and Komatsu models working on the same site. While the overall performance is acceptable, its speed is not as fast as some other competitors.
Fuel Consumption
Most of the work is done on a contract basis, where the construction site covers fuel costs. Under full load conditions, the fuel consumption is around 17-18 liters per hour, which is about 5-6 liters less than his Komatsu PC220-8. This demonstrates the DH220LC-7’s good fuel efficiency.
Performance - Engine: There have been no major issues with the engine since the excavator was purchased. It continues to operate smoothly and reliably.
- Hydraulic System: The hydraulic system has also performed well with no significant problems reported.
Dealer and After-Sales Service
The authorized Doosan dealer in Henan is Henan Qianlima Engineering Machinery Co., Ltd., which is one of the largest construction machinery dealerships in China. Mr. Wang mentions that the service provided by Qianlima is generally satisfactory, noting that their response times are quick, and they have a strong network for support.
As Mr. Wang owns several pieces of construction equipment, he usually handles repairs himself, which reflects the professionalization and scale of his equipment rental business. This also indicates that he has developed a solid understanding of machinery maintenance and repair.
Spare Parts
Having access to a lot of industry information, Mr. Wang does not purchase spare parts from the dealer once the warranty period expires. He is aware that many of the parts are not produced by the manufacturers themselves but are outsourced to other companies. By sourcing parts directly from the original manufacturers or their suppliers, he is able to save a significant amount of money. Mr. Wang's deep knowledge of machinery, along with his strong maintenance capabilities, enables him to avoid being misled by manufacturers or dealers — a valuable lesson for other users to follow.
Overall Evaluation
In summary, Mr. Wang is generally satisfied with the performance of the Doosan DH220LC-7. The excavator is stable and reliable, and the dealer’s service is good. However, it is slightly slower than other excavators in terms of work efficiency, making it more suitable for entry-level excavator users. Despite the speed being a bit of a drawback, its solid performance and lower operating costs make it a good option for users looking for a dependable and cost-efficient machine.
|
|
|
Komatsu PC200-8 Excavator User Report |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 03:17 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
This interview features a user named "Komatsu-8" from Tangshan, Hebei, who owns three excavators: a Caterpillar 345D, a Komatsu PC200-8, and a Caterpillar 320C. The focus of this article will be on the PC200-8, which has accumulated over 6,000 hours of usage, providing insights into its performance and user experience.
Purchase Information
Komatsu-8 purchased the Komatsu PC200-8 in January 2008 from the Hebei dealer, Shijiazhuang Tianyuan Company. The full price of the excavator at the time was 985,000 RMB, and it has now been in use for 6,080 hours.
Working Conditions
The Komatsu PC200-8 has mainly been used for earthmoving tasks, including road construction and foundation digging. It is rarely used for rock work. The excavator has shown good adaptability for daily tasks and operates efficiently in regular construction environments.
Work Efficiency
During operation, Komatsu-8 has been satisfied with the excavator’s speed. For example, when loading soft soil into a 23-cubic-meter dump truck, it takes just 3-4 minutes to complete the task. When compared to other excavators on the same site, only the Sumitomo brand excavators are slightly faster. Other brands cannot match the speed of the Komatsu PC200-8.
Fuel Consumption
Under full load, the fuel consumption in A mode is 19 liters per hour, while in economy mode (E mode), it drops to 17 liters per hour. Due to the electric fuel injection (EFI) engine, the machine is more sensitive to fuel quality and requires high-quality fuel.
Performance - Engine: At 3,681 hours, three of the fuel injectors malfunctioned. The after-sales service explained that the issue was caused by poor fuel quality. Each injector cost 5,690 RMB to replace, which is quite expensive. Due to urgency, Komatsu-8 opted to replace the injectors through the dealer’s service station.
- Hydraulic System: The hydraulic system has generally performed well with no major issues. However, the small arm and bucket cylinders have become severely discolored. Despite the service station’s efforts, they have not provided a satisfactory explanation. The hydraulic oil was changed at 4,950 hours, and the service station recommended changing it at 5,000 hours. Filters and oil are regularly replaced, and all parts are from the original manufacturer. The issue with the cylinders is still under negotiation with the dealer.
Dealer Service
Komatsu-8 praised the after-sales service provided by the Hebei dealer, Shijiazhuang Tianyuan. Since the construction site is relatively close to the Tangshan branch, the dealer’s service team typically arrives within an hour of being called to resolve any issues.
Parts
The main drawback for Komatsu-8 has been the cost of parts. Due to the EFI engine, all parts must be purchased through the dealer, and the prices are considered quite high. Specifically, when the fuel injectors needed replacement, the cost for each injector was 5,960 RMB. While the price is high, Komatsu-8 had no choice but to go through the dealer to get the parts due to the urgency of the situation.
Overall Evaluation
In general, Komatsu-8 is quite satisfied with the Komatsu PC200-8. The excavator is highly efficient, and the after-sales service is responsive. There have been no significant issues during its use, and it has performed well in its designated tasks. However, there are some downsides, including higher-than-expected fuel consumption and the expensive cost of parts. Komatsu-8 hopes that Komatsu and its dealers will take user costs into account and work on improving the pricing of parts and services. With these improvements, the Komatsu PC200-8 can gain even more recognition from users.
|
|
|
Sumitomo SH210A5 Excavator User Experience |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 03:09 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
In this article, we share the experience of a user named “罩的住,” an engineering supervisor, who has been using the Sumitomo SH210A5 excavator. After graduating from university, he started working in the construction supervision industry, which sparked his interest in excavators commonly found at construction sites. In 2008, he purchased a second-hand Hitachi ZX225US tail-less excavator, but due to numerous small issues, he sold it for 280,000 RMB. In 2010, he decided to purchase a brand-new Sumitomo SH210A5 and began his journey in the excavator rental business.
Purchasing Decision:
When it came time to purchase an excavator, “罩的住” considered three models: the Kato HD820-R (his first choice), Kobelco SK200 Ultra 8, and the Sumitomo SH210. Due to the high down payment required for the Kato excavator and the inflexible financing policies, he decided to abandon it. He was also concerned about the quality of the domestic engine and hydraulic components of the Kobelco SK200 Ultra 8. After considering these factors, he chose the Sumitomo SH210A5, whose core components were all imported from Japan and had more flexible purchasing policies.
Purchase Details: - Financing: Down payment of 270,000 RMB
- Remaining balance: 60,000 RMB (due one year later)
- Total price: 1.09 million RMB
Construction Conditions:
After purchasing the excavator, it was primarily used for hourly rental, covering earthwork and rockwork tasks. The user noted that the Sumitomo performed very well in earthwork, being fast and powerful. However, when performing rockwork, he felt some noticeable wobble in the connection between the boom and arm. "It didn’t feel as solid as the Caterpillar on the same site. I'm not sure if it's the quality of the steel used," he commented.
Work Efficiency:
The Sumitomo SH210A5 displayed excellent work efficiency. It was the fastest machine on the job site for tasks like loading trucks and digging. According to the user, "None of the same model machines on the site could beat my Sumitomo 210," indicating that the SH210A5 truly excels in speed.
Fuel Consumption:
The fuel economy of the Sumitomo SH210A5 was quite good, especially compared to other machines in the same category. According to the user, the fuel consumption in Mode A (the light mode) was 105 RMB per hour, while in other modes it ranged from 85 to 88 RMB per hour, making it one of the most fuel-efficient machines on the site. The fuel modes available are:- Mode A: Light mode, offering the best fuel efficiency.
- Mode H: Speed mode, suited for faster operations.
- Mode SP: Balanced mode, offering a mix of speed and power.
When running the air conditioning in Mode A, the fuel consumption was approximately 100 RMB per hour, which is considered very economical for its class.
Performance and Issues:
- Engine: No issues reported.
- Hydraulic System: No failures experienced.
- Undercarriage: No issues reported.
- Cab: The cab is designed with luxury and practicality in mind. It features large glass windows for a wide field of view, additional seating for apprentices, hooks for clothes, and even a refrigerator, all contributing to a user-friendly design. However, the user noted that the cab’s shock absorption and sealing performance were not as good as those of Hitachi or Caterpillar machines, and the operator felt significant impact when working with rock. The seat also lacked the same level of comfort as the other brands.
- Sound System: The sound system was noted as having low volume, making it difficult to hear clearly at times.
After-Sales Service:
The Sumitomo SH210A5 was purchased through the agent Jiangxi Zhongrui Engineering Machinery Co., Ltd. The after-sales service has been commendable. On one occasion, the operator reported that the walking warning light was not working, and the service personnel drove to the site at 10 PM. Upon arrival, they discovered it was a false alarm caused by the operator not wanting to work overtime. Despite the lack of an actual issue, the agent’s response was quick and professional, leaving the user satisfied with their service.
Conclusion:
The Sumitomo SH210A5 excavator, with its flexible purchasing policies, fully imported core components, and excellent fuel efficiency, proved to be an excellent choice for “罩的住.” To date, he has been very satisfied with the performance of the excavator. The machine has demonstrated great efficiency in terms of work performance and fuel consumption. As time goes on, the user will continue to monitor the excavator’s performance and provide further updates.
|
|
|
Slope Climbing Excavators Using Cables and Winches |
Posted by: MikePhua - 06-26-2025, 02:48 PM - Forum: Operator Talking
- No Replies
|
 |
In certain challenging terrains, such as mountains or steep slopes, standard excavators might not have the capability to navigate efficiently. This is where excavators equipped with cables and winches come into play. These systems enhance the excavator's ability to climb slopes and work in difficult conditions. This article explores how cable and winch systems help excavators climb slopes and their application and advantages.
1. The Role of Cables and Winches
Cables and winches are primarily used to assist excavators in climbing slopes or performing tasks in tough, uneven terrain. They provide additional traction, allowing the excavator to move on slippery, muddy, or unstable surfaces, especially on steep inclines. The winch pulls the excavator up the slope, preventing it from losing traction and avoiding slipping or tipping over.
2. Enhanced Slope Climbing Capability
Standard tracked excavators might struggle with sufficient traction on steeper inclines. Cables and winches improve the excavator's climbing ability, especially on slopes exceeding a 30-degree angle. The additional support from cables allows the excavator to overcome challenging grades, ensuring it can move up the slope without sliding down or becoming stuck.
3. Real-World Applications
Cable and winch systems are especially useful in industries where steep terrain is common, such as mining, forestry, and disaster recovery. For example, in mountain construction, these systems help excavators overcome steep hills, ensuring they can reach the work site and perform excavation or other tasks. Additionally, they are vital for working in unstable or slippery environments where regular machines might struggle to operate effectively.
4. Safety and Stability
Excavators with cable and winch systems provide enhanced safety and stability compared to standard machines. The winch offers strong pulling power, ensuring the excavator remains stable during operations. This reduces the risk of tipping over or sliding, especially in precarious environments like muddy areas or steep slopes. In high-risk areas, such as mountains or wet conditions, this added security is essential for safe operation.
5. Equipment and Modification
Not all excavators come with built-in cables and winches. Typically, this functionality is available as an option from manufacturers or can be added later through aftermarket modifications. These systems often come with heavy-duty steel cables and electrically or hydraulically powered winches to ensure reliable operation in challenging terrains.
6. Advantages and Challenges
Advantages: - Increased Traction: Cables and winches provide additional pulling force, allowing the excavator to ascend steep slopes without losing traction.
- Versatility: These systems enable the excavator to perform in more varied environments, including mountain and wet conditions.
- Enhanced Safety: By supporting the excavator with cables, the risk of the machine losing traction and tipping is minimized.
Challenges:- Maintenance and Cost: The cable and winch systems require regular maintenance, and adding them to the excavator increases the initial investment.
- Operational Difficulty: Using cables and winches requires specific skills and experience, which can increase the complexity of operations.
- Terrain Limitations: While the system enhances slope climbing, it may still have limitations when faced with extremely steep or unstable ground.
7. Conclusion
Cables and winches provide excavators with the additional climbing power and stability needed for complex terrain work. Especially useful in mountain or difficult environments, these systems enhance an excavator’s versatility and safety. While they come with additional costs and maintenance, the benefits of improving the machine's slope-climbing capabilities and providing more operational flexibility in tough conditions make them a valuable addition for specific tasks.
|
|
|
|